Follow usTwitterFacebook


04 Sep 2016 Uncategorized No comments

'It's a link between heaven and earth': Pilgrims travel to site of Marian apparition

'Once (the pilgrims) have finished their devotion at the slipper chapel shrine, they then walk along what's called the Holy Mile into the village.' For more …

Read more

01 Apr 2015 Q&A No comments

Why does the Catholic Church send people to hell by excommunicating them?

Full Question Why does the Catholic Church send people to hell by excommunicating them? Answer It doesn't. The Church doesn't have the power to…

Read more

22 Sep 2016 News Comments (1)

Don't forget about the people of Nigeria! Boko Haram continues to kill Christians

With all the attention focused on the Islamic State in Syria and Iraq, it can be easy to forget that our Catholic and other Christian brothers and sisters in Ni…

Read more

17 Sep 2014 Vatican No comments

Sixth Meeting of Council of Cardinals Wraps Up

The director of the Holy See Press Office, Father Federico Lombardi, provided an update on the sixth meeting of the Council of Cardinals, which began on Monday,…

Read more

13 Jun 2016 Americas Asia-Pacific Europe News USA Vatican Comments (1)

Pope Francis Celebrates Mass for the Sick and disabled -

Love and solidarity are what make the world a better place, not a focus on physical perfection and hiding away those who do not fit a commercial ideal, Pope Fra…

Read more

14 Sep 2015 Middle East - Africa News No comments

Recent South African martyr beatified

Samuel Benedict Daswa (1946-90), a school teacher who was brutally murdered after he denounced witchcraft, was beatified as a martyr near Thohoyandou, South Afr…

Read more

05 Oct 2016 News No comments

Pope names successor to retiring Alaska archbishop

Archbishop Roger Schwietz of Anchorage will be replaced by Bishop Paul Etienne of Cheyenne Pope Francis accepts the resignation of Archbishop Roger Schwietz of…

Read more

23 May 2016 News No comments

Pope Francis sends message of condolence following EgyptAir crash

A telegram was sent on the Pope's behalf to Egyptian President Abdel Fattah Al Sisi Pope Francis sent a telegram on Friday expressing his condolences for the l…

Read more

02 Oct 2015 News USA No comments

Oregon gunman was targeting Christians, eyewitness claims

Chris Harper-Mercer was reportedly asking victims their religion before shooting them The gunmen who killed at least 9 people at a college shooting in the US…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

A belated apology to Cardinal Wilfrid Fox Napier

ROME — Crux owes Cardinal Wilfrid Fox Napier of Durban, South Africa, an apology. Although it’s coming later than it should, this piece is intended to deliver it.

Although it largely got lost amid a bigger controversy this week over a letter signed by several cardinals objecting to elements of the process at the 2015 Synod of Bishops, a smaller row broke out Tuesday over a Crux piece published the day before in which Napier was quoted as saying he shared concerns over a drafting committee for the synod’s final document, “challenging Pope Francis’ right to choose them.”

The interview was conducted by my Crux colleague, Inés San Martín, on Monday, who recorded it on her smartphone and then transcribed it. I listened to the recording and confirmed the transcript. What both of us heard was the following:

“One of the concerns was, and this I really would share, is the choice of the people that are drawing up the document, challenging Pope Francis’ right to choose them. If we’re going to get a fair expression of what the synod is about, what the Church in Africa really would like to see happening, we wouldn’t like to see the same kind of people on that committee that were there the last time, that caused us the grief that we had.”

At about 9 a.m. Tuesday, Napier called San Martín to say he had not challenged the pope’s right to make the appointments. Since that part of the recording was a bit unclear, we removed the line from the story.

At Tuesday’s daily Vatican briefing at 1 p.m., the Rev. Federico Lombardi read a denial from Napier that he had challenged the pope’s right to make the appointments. In response, Crux published the transcript quoted above at the bottom of the original article, noted that we had removed the line from the story, and considered the matter closed.


On Wednesday afternoon, Napier tweeted that he wanted to see me acknowledge he had been misquoted. I replied that while the quote was accurate, I accepted “100%” that it was not what he had meant to say. I assumed this was simply a matter of someone not expressing themselves correctly in a given moment, and believed the record had been set straight. I also sent Napier a private note saying the same thing.

On Thursday morning, I went back to the recording again to reassure myself the transcript was correct.

After repeatedly listening to it, it now seems entirely possible that at the same moment San Martín is heard saying “yeah” in response to Napier’s reference to the people drafting the document, Napier is saying “not” before the phrase about challenging the pope’s right to choose them.

Obviously, that changes the entire sense of what he was saying. It becomes, in essence, “While the pope has the right to do this, I share concerns about some of the people who have been chosen.”

There were two clear breakdowns, and for both, Crux takes full responsibility.

First, I should have listened to the recording more carefully on Monday before we published the piece, and either gone back to Napier for clarification or omitted the line altogether since it’s not fully clear what he was saying.


Cardinal Donald W. Wuerl of Washington left a session of the Synod of Bishops on the family at the Vatican Oct. 6. (CNS photo/Paul Haring)
Cardinals clash on doubts about process at the Synod of Bishops
Two quick thoughts on ‘letter-gate’ at the Synod of Bishops
Cardinal George Pell with his successor as archbishop of Sydney, Anthony Fisher. Pell reportedly hand-delivered a letter to Pope Francis signed by 13 cardinals unhappy with the synod process. (Getty)
Uncertainty surrounds cardinals’ letter voicing doubts about the synod
Second, I should have reviewed the recording immediately after Napier first raised an objection Tuesday morning, rather than doing so only 48 hours later.

To be clear, the names of San Martín, our Vatican correspondent, and Michael O’Loughlin, our national reporter, were also on Monday’s story, but none of the blame for these errors belongs to them. They were following my lead.

I could make the usual excuses about deadline pressures and so on, but the bottom line is that while I never meant to misrepresent Napier, that was the effect of these two mistakes.

My reputation and that of Crux is based on getting things right, and this is a case in which I didn’t do so. For that, above all to Napier but also to my colleagues and readers, I sincerely apologize.

By John L. Allen Jr.


Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories