Follow usTwitterFacebook


06 Oct 2016 News No comments

Thieves ransack Liverpool’s Catholic cathedral

Glass images were smashed and cash stolen early this morning Liverpool Metropolitan Cathedral was ransacked and vandalised in the early hours of this morning. …

Read more

09 Sep 2016 Articles No comments

Practical governance was not my forte, says Benedict XVI

In a book-length interview Benedict XVI says he was 'more of a professor' while Francis was a 'man of practical reform' While retired Pope Benedict XVI said or…

Read more

11 Aug 2016 News No comments

Catholic charity to support seminarians across the world after murder of Fr Hamel

Aid to the Church in Need is launching a campaign to support the training of 1,000 new priests Following the murder of Fr Jacques Hamel, the Italian arm of A…

Read more

14 Jun 2016 Vatican Comments (1)

Disabled people must not be hidden away, says Pope Francis

Francis celebrated Mass for the Year of Mercy jubilee of the sick and persons with disabilities Love and solidarity are what make the world a better place, not…

Read more

08 Sep 2015 Middle East - Africa News No comments

Burkina Faso’s bishops call for transparent elections

Describing political responsibility as a “high form of charity,” the bishops of Burkina Faso have issued a pastoral letter calling for “peaceful elections, free…

Read more

12 Sep 2015 Europe News No comments

Cardinal Marx: Pope's annulment reforms don't go far enough

The president of the German bishops' conference has said that the reform introduced in the annulment process by Pope Francis this week "does not solve the funda…

Read more

08 May 2016 United Kingdom No comments

Campaigners applaud Cameron’s caution on screening for Down’s syndrome

The prime minister said 'ethical issues' must be taken into account Campaigners have applauded David Cameron’s statement that new screening techniques must be …

Read more

11 Oct 2016 News Comments (2)

Read about what one priest said that made Pope Francis wipe tears from his eyes!

The Albanian priest whose testimony moved Pope Francis to tears in 2014 is one of the 17 international bishops and priests the Pope will elevate to the College …

Read more

20 Feb 2015 Articles Comments (9)

Eucharistic Miracles: Evidence of the Real Presence

At every Catholic Mass, following the command of Jesus himself, the celebrant raises the host and says, "Take this, all of you, and eat it: This is my body,…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Archbishop criticises George Osborne’s Brexit ‘scare stories’

Archbishop Peter Smith discussed the upcoming referendum in an interview with Vatican Radio

An archbishop has become the first senior Church leader in the UK to show public sympathy for the Brexit campaign.

European Union ambitions to turn the bloc into the super-state were wrong, said Archbishop Peter Smith of Southwark.

The quest for cohesion between European member states could not come at the price of their legitimate sovereignty, he said.

The archbishop said it was “hard to swallow” the loss of British sovereignty to the EU project of erecting a European “United States”.

He also denounced the single currency as a failure which hurt poor countries, adding that he was glad Britain had not signed up to it.

Archbishop Smith, the vice president of the Bishops’ Conference of England and Wales, also criticised the Remain campaign for attempting to “scare” the electorate into voting to stay in the EU when they go to the polls on June 23.

He dismissed as “ludicrous” the bleak economic forecasts predicted by George Osborne, the Chancellor of the Exchequer, in the event of a Brexit win.

“When we joined the European Union many decades ago, the chief arguments were about trade, that we would be better off and it would help the economy,” said Archbishop Smith.

“The problem is that the EU has become extremely bureaucratic,” he told Vatican Radio. “With this real fundamental desire to become more integrated, like a European (United) States – that, many of us find hard to swallow.

“I don’t think that is the right thing to do,” he said,

“The euro hasn’t worked particularly with the poorer countries in Europe – Greece, Portugal, Spain to an extent. It is not working with the euro and all of us are glad that we didn’t go into the euro because of the different economies on the continent of Europe.”

“I am very sceptical of the arguments the Chancellor makes. When he does a budget each year very often by the end of the year his forecasts are all over the place.

“When you look at the budgets even after 12 months very often the Chancellor is wrong because you can’t pin the economy down like that because it is so involved with the world economy which goes up and down.”

He added: “Most people are completely puzzled. They don’t know what the real arguments are and then they hear these scare stories like the Chancellor saying in 14 years’ time we will £4,000 plus less (worse off).

“With great respect to the Chancellor of the Exchequer I think it is ludicrous. He doesn’t know, and we don’t know.

“This is not the way to argue. It is on the broad issues – on solidarity of Europe, on the issues now of the Middle East and the migrant crisis, which is causing terrible problems, but particularly to the poorer countries of Europe, Greece for example.

“Turkey is neither in nor out at the moment. There is an awful lot of work to be done on the political side toward making the EU more cohesive without it over-taking the legitimate sovereignty of the particular countries.”

Archbishop Smith said that “The real difficulty is that there has been no clarity on either side of the argument” and that “there hasn’t been much argument at all.”

“There has been a lot of emotional speculation and so on,” he said.

“With respect to them all they treat each other like naughty teenagers – more personal abuse than giving us substantive arguments on both sides.”

It was a “great shame” that politicians were not giving the public the facts about Britain’s position in Europe, Archbishop Smith added.

“There ought to be a proper debate in the House of Lords and in Parliament – not to make a decision but to air and give reasonable arguments on both sides because most of what we hear is speculation.”

He said: “It is scaring people into following a particular line, whether in or out. It is not a good way of having a rational thought-out view about what is the best thing for the future for us and for Europe.”

It is the policy of the Catholic bishops never to direct the faithful how to vote in a General Election or a referendum.

Instead, they choose to highlight issues of concern which they wish voters to consider when casting their votes.

Last month, they issued a joint statement in which they urged Catholics to become fully informed of the arguments for and against EU membership ahead of the referendum, telling them that the outcome of the vote will have consequences for the future “not only of the UK but for Europe and for the world”.

The comments of Archbishop Smith, the chairman of the Bishops’ Department Christian Responsibility and Citizenship, reveal the divisions among the Catholic bishops over the referendum, however.

Cardinal Vincent Nichols, the Archbishop of Westminster and the leader of the Catholic Church in England and Wales, strongly indicated his support for the Remain camp when he told journalists that Britain would face “complex problems” if voters chose to leave the EU.

His predecessor, Cardinal Cormac Murphy-O’Connor, went further earlier this month when he forcefully backed Remain in an article in the Spectator.

Archbishop Smith said he was undecided about which way to vote but noted that one possible consequence of a Brexit victory could be disintegration of the EU as other countries followed Britain’s example and left the bloc.

He said: “In other countries in the EU a lot of people are getting very nervous about the way the EU is working. If we pull out there could be the danger of a chain reaction.”


Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories