18 Apr 2016 United Kingdom No comments

English and Welsh bishops fix a date for their National Eucharistic Congress

England and Wales fixed a date for its first National Eucharistic Congress in more than a dozen years. This week, at the bishops’ conference’s spring meeting…

Read more

16 Mar 2016 Middle East News No comments

UNICEF's Middle East director warns against an increasing number of child soldiers

According to a report published by UNICEF, March 15th marked the 5 year anniversary of the Syrian conflict. The Syrian five-year-old conflict has forced near…

Read more

26 Jul 2016 News No comments

Pope to nuns: ‘It’s OK to use social media, but don’t let it distract from your vocation’

The Pope said smartphones and computers offer 'useful help', but should not 'become an obstacle' A Vatican official says the number of nuns who dedicate thei…

Read more

07 Sep 2014 USA Comments (2)

Church serves women 'the rest of the world has left behind'

Washington D.C., Sep 7, 2014 / 04:32 pm .- Recent claims that the Catholic Church disregards women fail to acknowledge the Church’s critical work to support wom…

Read more

26 Aug 2015 Articles Q&A Comments (1)

Sharing Duties With Concelebrants

Answered by Legionary of Christ Father Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy and dean of theology at the Regina Apostolorum university. Q: Is it permissible at…

Read more

25 Mar 2016 News Vatican No comments

Pope washes feet of several refugees including Muslims, Hindus and Copts

On Thursday, Pope Francis visited a refugee center to wash and kiss the feet of several refugees; including Muslims, Hindus and Copts — a gesture of solidarity …

Read more

23 Sep 2016 News Comments (1)

St. Padre Pio helps dying newborn miraculously recover after 25 DAYS on life support

Three-month-old Caitlin Dooley suffered from a life-threatening heart condition since the day she was born. Just when the Dooley family began to lose hope, St. …

Read more

06 Oct 2016 News Comments (4)

WATCH Woman's soul rises from her body in ASTONISHING footage

CCTV footage recording a busy road captured the moment a woman's soul leaped from her body following a fatal accident. The video was posted to YouTube Septem…

Read more

25 Jun 2016 Articles Comments (1)

Brexit and Catholic Social Teaching

The United Kingdom—and at the moment it is still united—has voted to leave the European Union. Are there any specifically Catholic aspects to this decision? On …

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Are “This is the body of Christ” and “I believe” acceptable substitutes for “The body of Christ” and “Amen”?

Full Question

When distributing Holy Communion, the extraordinary ministers have been told to say “This is the body of Christ” instead of “the body of Christ,” and the communicants are to respond with “I believe” instead of “Amen.” Our priest says it’s more meaningful this way and has assured us that he is authorized to make such changes. Is this true?


No. A priest has no authority to make creative changes to the Mass. He is to follow the rubrics as outlined in the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, which is binding on all Roman Rite celebrations of the liturgy.

According to the Code of Canon Law, “In celebrating the sacraments the liturgical books approved by competent authority are to be observed faithfully; accordingly, no one is to add, omit, or alter anything in them on one’s own authority” (CIC 846 §1).

The General Instruction of the Roman Missal states:

If Communion is given only under the species of bread, the priest raises the host slightly and shows it to each, saying, " Corpus Christi " (the body of Christ). The communicant replies "Amen" and receives the sacrament either on the tongue or, where this is allowed and if the communicant so chooses, in the hand. As soon as the communicant receives the host, he or she consumes it entirely. (161)
If Communion from the chalice is carried out by intinction, each communicant, holding a communion-plate under the chin, approaches the priest, who holds a vessel with the sacred particles, a minister standing at his side and holding the chalice. The priest takes a host, dips it partly into the chalice and, showing it, says, " Corpus et Sanguis Christi " (the body and blood of Christ). The communicant responds "Amen," receives the sacrament in the mouth from the priest, and then withdraws. (287)

The USCCB’s Committee on the Liturgy document “Extraordinary Ministers of Holy Communion at Mass” states:

The proper and only permissible form for distributing Holy Communion is to offer the consecrated bread by saying, "the body of Christ" and to offer the consecrated wine by saying, "the blood of Christ." No other words or names should be added; and the formula should not be edited in any way.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories