08 Oct 2015 News USA No comments

South Carolina bishop asks for prayers and support for families affected by floods

Authorities said at least 14 people died after flooding in the US state earlier this month Bishop Robert Guglielmone of Charleston asked for prayers for the …

Read more

20 Oct 2015 Articles Comments (17)

Edifying Proof of Christ in the Christ in the Eucharist

Protestant attacks on the Catholic Church often focus on the Eucharist. This demonstrates that opponents of the Church—mainly Evangelicals and Fundamentalists—r…

Read more

10 Dec 2014 Q&A Comments (1)

Is it okay to buy a lottery ticket? I know we are not supposed to gamble.

Full Question Is it okay to buy a lottery ticket? I know we are not supposed to gamble. Answer The Church does not forbid gambling, so long as it…

Read more

29 Jun 2015 Uncategorized Comments (1)

Mosque aids Catholic church in Canada after acts of vandalism

A mosque in Mississauga, Canada, has donated thousands of dollars to help a neighbor in need. A Catholic church in the area needed a clean-up after acts of vand…

Read more

16 Sep 2016 News No comments

New motu proprio on harmonizing codes of canon law: full English translation

The first English translation of the Pope's announcement on harmonising Eastern and Latin canon law. Translated by Fr James Bradley and Ed Condon APOSTOLIC LET…

Read more

29 Sep 2014 Articles No comments

Extraordinary Form 101

On July 7, 2007, Pope Benedict XVI launched one of the boldest papal initiatives since Vatican II: He declared that the traditional liturgy of the Roman rite, w…

Read more

29 Jun 2015 Exhortations Vatican Comments (1)

Don’t fish in aquariums, Francis tells future Vatican diplomats

Clerics who work in the Vatican’s diplomatic corps are not called to be “senior officials of a state" or “a self-preserving superior caste, welcome in worldly l…

Read more

13 Jan 2016 Q&A No comments

Can grandparents be godparents for their grandchild?

Full Question Can grandparents be godparents for their grandchild? Answer Part of the reason for having godparents is to help provide for the child…

Read more

23 Jul 2015 Q&A No comments

How many plenary or partial indulgences can one receive per day?

Full Question How many plenary or partial indulgences can one receive per day? Answer In most cases only one plenary indulgence may be acquired per…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Bishop urges Catholics to affirm truths ‘undermined’ in Amoris Laetitia

Bishop Schneider said the document might lead to widespread confusion over doctrine and the sacraments

Bishop Athanasius Schneider has said that parts of Amoris Laetitia “contain a real spiritual danger" and has called on all Catholics to affirm doctrines which he says the document calls into doubt.

Responding to an open letter from The Remnant newspaper, Bishop Schneider, an auxiliary bishop of Astana in Kazakhstan, said some parts of Pope Francis’s apostolic exhortation may cause “doctrinal confusion". He said its words about the sacraments could lead to practice which undermines the sacraments of Confession, marriage and the Eucharist.

The Remnant describes itself as “part of the ‘loyal opposition’" and says it “defends the Pope as the legitimate successor of St Peter".

But the newspaper has been highly critical of Pope Francis, and in an open letter to Bishop Schneider, columnist Christopher Ferrara wrote that Amoris Laetitia was a “catastrophic text" containing “destructive novelties".

He noted that the bishop had already warned of the possible effects of Amoris Laetitia. In April, Bishop Schneider raised several concerns about the document, saying that it could be used to justify admitting the divorced and remarried to Communion.

The bishop said in April that the document failed to quote the teaching of John Paul II’s Familiaris Consortio, which reaffirmed the Church’s traditional practice of not admitting to Communion the divorced and civilly remarried, except when they lived in “complete continence".

Bishop Schneider wrote that, because of the way Amoris Laetitia was being interpreted, it could lead to the conclusion that: “The sixth Divine Commandment, which prohibits any sexual act that does not take place within a valid marriage, would no longer be universally valid, but would admit exceptions".

He added: “The uncompromising words of Christ commanding men to observe the commandments of God always and in all circumstances, and even to take upon themselves considerable suffering in order to do so, in other words, to accept the Cross, would no longer be valid as absolute truth: ‘And if your right hand causes you to sin, cut it off and throw it away. For it is better that you lose one of your members than that your whole body be cast into hell’ (Matthew 5:30)."

In his reply to Ferrara last week, Bishop Schneider praised Ferrara’s open letter as “clear and beautiful" and said he agreed with its analysis of Chapter 8. The bishop said that Amoris Laetitia contained “ambiguous expressions" which had worrying implications.

“Indeed, they contain a real spiritual danger, which will cause doctrinal confusion, a fast and easy spreading of heterodox doctrines concerning marriage and moral law, and also the adoption and consolidation of the praxis of admitting divorced and remarried to Holy Communion, a praxis which will trivialise and profane, as to say, at one blow three sacraments: the sacrament of Marriage, of Penance, and of the Most Holy Eucharist," the bishop wrote.

He said that “all Catholics", clergy and lay people, “should with one voice (‘una voce’) make a profession of fidelity, enunciating concretely and clearly all those Catholic truths, which are in some expressions of Amoris Laetitia undermined or ambiguously disfigured. It would be a kind of a ‘Credo’ of the people of God." He did not clarify how this public statement should be prepared.

The bishop stressed the duty of “filial deference to the vicar of Christ", while pointing out that not every papal statement is infallible and that Amoris Laetitia does not claim to be definitive or to change canon law.

Bishop Schneider also suggested that moral and dogmatic theologians should issue “a solid analysis of all ambiguous and objectively erroneous expressions in Amoris Laetitia".

Bishop Schneider is the most senior churchman to have expressed such major reservations about Amoris Laetitia. His intervention follows similar criticisms by the philosopher Robert Spaemann, an associate of Popes John Paul II and Benedict XVI. Spaemann said the document contradicted the Church’s teaching on Communion, and that it would lead to “confusion" and possibly an eventual schism “at the heart of the Church". Spaemann added: “God forbid that."



  1. Tom Rafferty Reply

    I get a kick out of seeing the Catholic Church use the words “Truth” and “Dogma” in the same sentence. Truth is best determined through science and its methods. Dogma is unsupported asserts. The fact that that there are tens of thousands of Christian denominations with competing Christian “Truth” claims is all an objective person needs to see this situation.

  2. Arthur Dallas Reply

    Thomas R, the whole point of the Primacy of the Papacy and Sacred Magisterium is to keep us from error, and it was to that end that Christ established His Church under the eternal vigilance and guidance of the Holy Spirit. This is the most essential part of Catholicism; our very deposit of Faith.

    1. Tom Rafferty Reply

      And, you KNOW this how? (Not a rhetorical question)

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories