Latest

18 Nov 2014 Q&A No comments

Do our beliefs and traditions come from God or are they of human origin?

Full Question Is it correct to say that the traditions and beliefs we as Catholics hold are not manmade but originated from Jesus, who gave the "guidelines…

Read more

10 May 2016 Articles No comments

Teen Sex Scandals and Society’s Double Standard

Last week former Speaker of the House Dennis Hastert was sentenced to fifteen months in prison. Many people who pay attention to the news casually might think t…

Read more

26 Feb 2016 Articles No comments

A New Fisher of Men - St. Louis the Crusader

For three weeks, King Louis IX of France lay dying in his tent in the shadow of the old Carthaginian wall. Hard by the plains of Zama, where Scipio Africanus ha…

Read more

28 Jan 2016 Articles Comments (4)

The Futility of Starting Your Own Church

The Church Comes Home is a book about the ultimate in atomistic Christianity: starting your own church in your own home. The authors are Robert and Julia Banks.…

Read more

19 Sep 2015 News USA Comments (1)

The White House invited some gay Catholics to the pope’s reception, and the right wing is furious

When President Barack Obama and First Lady Michelle Obama greet Pope Francis at the White House Wednesday, which kinds of Catholics should be there to witness t…

Read more

11 Dec 2015 Articles Comments (1)

Responsible Parenthood Guide by Pope John paul II

General audience of August 1, 1984. 1. For today we have chosen the theme of "responsible parenthood" in the light of the Constitution "Gaudium et spes" and …

Read more

17 Nov 2015 Asia-Pacific News Comments (12)

Priest's body found floating on a river in China

Fr Pedro Yu Heping a Popular webmaster in China that owned a popular site that engaged many Chinese Catholics in China. Fr Pedro Yu Heping was found dead floati…

Read more

08 Jul 2015 Articles No comments

The Most Problematic Kind of 'Privilege'

We need to be talking about the privilege that matters most. Much has been written about privilege in academic settings over the past few decades. There's the…

Read more

03 Jun 2016 Americas Europe News USA Vatican No comments

Pope Francis: 'Life is short; start forgiving, making amends'

Mercy recognises that life is short and that so much good needs to be done that there is no time to waste in making amends, Pope Francis told priests. “That …

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
«
»

Can a Catholic attend an Anglican mass as a visitor?

Full Question

Can a Catholic attend an Anglican mass as a visitor?

Answer

Yes. However, because the Anglican church does not have valid holy orders, eucharistic intercommunion is not possible. The Catechism of the Catholic Church states the following:

Ecclesial communities derived from the Reformation and separated from the Catholic Church have not preserved the proper reality of the eucharistic mystery in its fullness, especially because of the absence of the sacrament of Holy Orders. It is for this reason that, for the Catholic Church, eucharistic intercommunion with these communities is not possible. (CCC 1400)










22 comments

  1. Michael Steele Reply

    The Anglican Communion does have the exact same Sacraments as the Roman Catholic Church, including Holy Orders and Apostolic Sucession. Need to find a better answer and research other churches before posting answers. Thanks!

    1. Justin Reply

      Don’t get mad at the Truth.

      1. Gerry Kenny Reply

        Do some research…the Anglican church does not believe that the body and blood of Christ is present but to the real Apostolic Catholic Church from Christ not King Henry(6 wives)church it is the whole truth and base of the One True Faith…..”One Holy Catholic Apostolic”!!

    2. Rigel Casmual Reply

      Not really. Because the Anglican Church broke away from the Catholic Church, it lost the true faith, therefore, even though they would have the sacraments, they are not truly sacramental, as for my friend who also replied to this discussion, they are invalid.

  2. Timothy J. Corbitt Reply

    They have them, but as the Catechism above states, they are not Valid, as they broke faith from the One True Church, so that a King who wished to commit adultery against his faithful wife, could get a divorce.

  3. Michael Steele Reply

    Ironically the Orthodox Church will inform you that the Roman Catholic Church (a Reformation Church) broke from the One Truth Faith, and on that basis extends Holy Communion to only practicing Orthodox faithful. Kind of silly……

  4. Kay Reply

    Holy communion within the Catholic Church is seen as a sacrament

  5. Jelle Sophie (Super Astra Sophia) Reply

    Then we must go back to the great chism of 1054 AD. Who was right in the first place? And offcourse you can attend the Anglican mass. In the first place because the Anglican church has it’s foundation on the Catholic church and second because it would be inpolite. This church made changes over time in there lithurgy as did the Catholic Church when the pope began to state that he was the highest power on earth, the vicar of Christ on earth. Everything evolves and it is meaningfull to attend a mass to see the differences and the resemblances that ake our cultures much more richer.

  6. D Reply

    The answer here is actually Heritical. Every moral theology manual would tell you that to actively participate in a Protestant service would be a mortal sin.

    Pope Pius IX, Graves ac diuturnae (# 4), March 23, 1875, speaking of a non-Catholic sect: “They [the faithful] should totally shun their religious celebrations, their buildings, and their chairs of pestilence which they have with impunity established to transmit the sacred teachings. They should shun their writings and all contact with them. They should not have any dealings or meetings with usurping priests and apostates from the faith who dare to exercise the duties of an ecclesiastical minister without possessing a legitimate mission or any jurisdiction."

    You should visit
    Vaticancatholic.com
    For more information on these issues

  7. Anoka Uchenna Reply

    Modern day catholic worshippers cares less about places of worship whether in a catholic or Anglican church,all they are eager to hear is true words of God that will change their situation at that very point.

    1. Cesar Reply

      There is no such thing as a ‘Modern’ Catholic. You are either Catholic or you are lying to yourself. Using the word modern implies that the Catholic Church has somehow changed its teachings.

  8. Lynette Courtiers Reply

    I was born and raised in a Anglican church. I was quite a good Anglican,and i enjoyed my faith very much. When i got married i changed my faith to Catholic. And as far as im concerned i am still praying to the same God. So to me there is no right and wrong. We all say the our father.

  9. Timothy J. Corbitt Reply

    So there is no such thing as right and wrong? So why go to church at all if that is your belief.

  10. jon Reply

    The question should be rephrased.. can a Roman Catholic attend an Anglican mass as a visitor?

  11. Lynda Reply

    It seems to me that Catholic bishops who became Anglicans, then ordaining priests would have passed down the apostolic succession making the Sacraments valid.

    1. Cesar Reply

      Wrong. Once the Bishops broke away from the Catholic Church (by force), their ordinations were deemed as invalid.

  12. Maleho Reply

    God is Love and honestly doesn’t derive any joy in infighting or relegation of his oneness which is the Holy Trinity! He hears all prayers and accepts all sacraments equally

  13. Msgr. James Rodgers Reply

    I am an Anglican priest, though my Apostolic lines descend from Catholic, Orthodox, and Old Catholic lines. The Vatican itself considers those like me validly ordained, though illicit. My sacraments are the same as yours. All seven of them. Try not to be so proud. That is the way of hubris and error. Would Jesus approve? I think not.

  14. Passion of Christ Reply

    Catholic, Anglican or any church you believed on WILL NEVER take you to HEAVEN rather righteousness and obeying God’s commandments as in the holy bible. Church doctrines and sacraments will not take you to heaven. PRAY FOR GOD SALVATION.

  15. Johnny Reply

    There can never be no two original versions of the same thing. You can either be a catholic or you are a duplicate. Though God will look at what reason / intention that took you to an Anglican church. So i think

  16. Julie Reply

    Pope Leo XIII wrote a “Papal Bull” concerning Anglican orders in 1896. This Document followed an intense study by both Roman Catholic and Anglican theologians on the Anglican ordination rite. It particularly focused on a 100 year period in which Anglicans had eliminated the words used in effecting and administering the sacraments. This was called the “Edwardian period” in which The simple words, “Receive the Holy Ghost” we’re used in the laying on of hands. Following that 100 years it was decided by the Anglican hierarchy that these words were insufficient and the ordination rite was edited once again. In the end it all comes down to a belief in the authority of the Pope and the Roman Catholic Church. Many Anglicans revere the position of the Bishop of Rome but do not respect his authority. ThIs is what makes them Protestants….they PROTEST the authority of Rome. Without that authority there would be no creed and no scriptures. Here is a link to the papal bull online:

    http://www.papalencyclicals.net/Leo13/l13curae.htm

  17. Marie-Rose Stanek Reply

    I have met with true believers in various Christian denominations. The Roman Catholic church was my home in my youth, then ten years without anything. For thirty years God placed me in the Anglican church, in an International setting : England and Benelux, I experienced the Charismatic revival there and fully read the Bible for the first time. Today I am back in the Roman Catholic Church in France by God’s will, even though I find the tradition rather heavy at times. I occasionaly enjoy fellowship with membres of other denominations. I think that what matters is really recognising what we all have in common that is ‘Jesus Christ our saviour. Endless discussions about what is the real church is only making things confusing and a bad exemple for outsiders. This is what Paul says in one of his letters.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories