Follow usTwitterFacebook


09 Sep 2016 News No comments

Chinese authorities arrest Vatican-appointed bishop

Coadjutor bishop arrested before he could take control of Wenzhou diocese, reports claim Chinese authorities have arrested the coadjutor bishop of Wenzhou, Chi…

Read more

23 Jul 2015 Q&A No comments

Does the Church approve of Christian Seders held at parishes?

Full Question Does the Church approve of Christian Seders held at parishes? Answer Although the Church has not expressly forbidden Christian Seders…

Read more

26 Feb 2016 Americas Asia-Pacific Europe News USA Vatican Comments (8)

Pope Francis suffering from Fever: All appointments cancelled

The Vatican's Spokesman, Fr. Federico Lombardi SJ announced on Thursday 25th of February that the Holy Father, Pope Francis after his usual morning mass has can…

Read more

13 Jan 2017 Articles Comments (1)

Here are 10 great reasons why Planned Parenthood must be defunded

The Ethics and Religious Liberty Commission of the Southern Baptist Convention has published 10 reasons why taxpayers should defund Planned Parenthood. Thanks t…

Read more

02 Nov 2016 News No comments

Norbertine prior becomes apostolic administrator of the Falklands

Fr Hugh Allan has been appointed Apostolic Administrator of the Prefecture of the Falkland Islands The Prior of the Norbertine Priory of Our Lady of Sorrows an…

Read more

04 Jun 2015 Articles Q&A No comments

Does The Church Believe in Yoga, Zen, Tai Chi, Chakra e.t.c

Issue: Should Christians look to non-Christian methods of meditation to draw closer to God? What are the more popular non-Christian methods of today? Can the Ch…

Read more

13 Jan 2016 Q&A Comments (3)

Are Catholics required to tithe 10 percent of their income to the Church?

Full Question Are Catholics required to tithe 10 percent of their income to the Church? Answer Catholics are under no obligation to tithe a certain…

Read more

09 Sep 2016 Articles Comments (5)

Did Matthew, Mark, Luke, and John Really Write the Gospels?

Critics of the New Testament often claim that the names of the authors of the Gospels were added after they had already been in circulation in the early Church.…

Read more

25 May 2015 Articles No comments

'I find God in suffering': The gripping life and death of Kayla Mueller

Kayla Mueller, the young human rights activist who was killed earlier this year while being held hostage by ISIS, was a woman of faith with a heart full of comp…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Cardinal Sarah and the Vatican: what people are saying

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

Cardinal Robert Sarah’s request to priests to celebrate mass ad orientem, and the response from the Vatican, have provoked much commentary. “It is highly unusual for the Vatican to publicly slap down a Prince of the Church,” wrote Christopher Lamb, seeing the Vatican statement (which followed a private audience between pope and cardinal) as a rebuke to Cardinal Sarah.

That was the standard interpretation – though Jeff Ostrowski asked where, exactly, the rebuke was supposed to be. For a start, Ostrowski pointed out, the Vatican merely clarified that there would be no new rules – a possibility which Cardinal Sarah had not actually raised.

But the terms of the Vatican statement were soon questioned by some observers. In particular, these words were challenged:

It is therefore good to recall that in the General Order of the Roman Missale (Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani), that contains the norms relating to the Eucharistic celebration and (which) are still fully in force, No. 299 states that “the altar is built separated from the wall, so as to be able to move around it easily and to celebrate looking towards the people, which thing is convenient to realize wherever possible.”

The same passage was quoted by Cardinal Nichols in his request to priests not to accede to Cardinal Sarah’s request. Bloggers includingCorpus Christi Watershed, Fr Ray Blake, and Fr John Zuhlsdorf argued that this was a mistranslation. The “wherever possible” clause referred to where you put the altar, not which way you celebrate Mass. But Jonathan Day interpreted the clause as ambiguous.

Meanwhile, Joseph Shaw argued that the episode vindicated a traditionalist critique of post-Vatican II liturgical reform: “I admire and support priests who make the change to ad orientem in the Ordinary Form. What I can’t do is defend them against the kinds of arguments which will inevitably be brought against them: that what they are doing is contrary to thrust of the post-Conciliar reform. Because it is.”

However, Fr Hugh Somerville-Knapman suggested that the cardinal’s invitation would eventually bear fruit: “The young laity and the young clergy and seminarians, in whose hands lies the future of the Church on earth for the next few generations at least, are now far more up to speed on the issues … when the forces seeking to put Cardinal Sarah’s genie back in its bottle use highly deficient arguments, the young will see it, and will spurn it, even scorn it.”

In tomorrow’s Catholic Herald , Fr Mark Drew argues that we really can have it both ways. Stay tuned…


1 comment

  1. Patrick Gannon Reply

    The Catholic Church is floundering around with financial scandals, sex abuse scandals, resistance from those opposed to the RCC’s contraception policies that indirectly contribute to the deaths of thousands of children and AIDs patients every month, a Zika virus that threatens to give the next generation of Catholics shrunken heads if they follow that policy, global threats and concerns – and the Church is talking about what direction the priest should face.
    So glad you have your priorities in order….

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories