Latest

16 Aug 2016 Americas News USA Vatican No comments

Pope prays for exploited women on the Feast of the Assumption

Celebrating the feast of the Assumption just three days after visiting a group of young women rescued from the sex trade, Pope Francis prayed for all exploited …

Read more

16 Sep 2015 News Vatican No comments

Pope Francis souvenirs: Cheesy, snuggly, silly, solar-powered, and charitable

Creative and commercial attempts to cash in on Pope Francis’ upcoming US visit this month know (almost) no limits. Whether you brave the crowds to see Pope F…

Read more

15 Dec 2015 News Vatican No comments

3,500 fake Vatican parchments seized by the Italian Security

The Security higher alertness was not meant just to check and prevent all intended attacks promised by the ISIS terrorist group but to also check the dignity an…

Read more

24 Oct 2015 Americas News No comments

Catholics in Cuba Appeal to Government for Freedom

The Archdiocese of Havana in Cuba has used their magazine published on Thursday to plea with the Cuban government to grant breathing room for religious practice…

Read more

23 Dec 2014 Q&A Comments (29)

Jesus was humble, so why does the pope act like a king?

Full Question When we think of Jesus, a humble man comes to mind. But when we think of the pope what comes to mind is a man wearing custom clothing, sittin…

Read more

29 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (6)

Isn't gambling a sin? How can you Catholics justify playing bingo in church?

Full Question Isn't gambling a sin? How then can you Catholics justify playing bingo?--and in church yet! Answer First of all, the stereotype…

Read more

05 Nov 2016 News Comments (2)

Catholic governor faces massive Islamist protest over Koran remarks

Protesters in the Indonesian capital of Jakarta called for the governor to be arrested Tens of thousands of hardline Muslims marched on Friday on the centre of…

Read more

19 Jan 2016 News Vatican No comments

Pope Francis asks his audience to pray for victims of Indonesia and Burkina Faso attack victims

Pope Francis on Sunday during his Angelus prayer addressed the audience at the St. Peter's Square. "Dear migrants and refugees", he said, "each of you carries …

Read more

22 Oct 2015 News USA No comments

Aid for Syrian refugee crisis falls far short, Congress told

Although numerous countries and organizations are working together and putting billions of dollars into relief efforts, “the scale of suffering has outpaced the…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
«
»

Did Christ actually go to hell?

In a broad sense the term “hell” refers to any place where one goes to after death before the resurrection of Christ. This includes Limbo which is a more specific term used to refer to both the place unbaptized infants were believed to go (We know God cannot leave them as they’re innocent of personal sins) and where our dead patriarchs went after death including Abraham, Moses, etc since none of them could actually enter heaven until Christ resurrected.

1. The first meaning is that Christ experienced death as every man. This is the first meaning the Apostles had in mind when they preached.

2. Where Christ actually went isn’t the “Hell” of the damned, but to “Limbo” to set free all the holy ones who had died before his coming. The word “Hell” was also used to speak of “Limbo” in the ancient times since they all are deprived of the Vision of God, however those in Limbo were at rest.

3. Jesus destroyed the power of death to bring life to all who believe in him:

CCC 635 says:

 

 "Christ went down into the depths of death so that "the dead will hear the voice of the Son of God, and those who hear will live." Jesus, "the Author of life", by dying destroyed "him who has the power of death, that is, the devil, and [delivered] all those who through fear of death were subject to lifelong bondage."  Henceforth the risen Christ holds "the keys of Death and Hades", so that "at the name of Jesus every knee should bow, in heaven and on earth and under the earth."










29 comments

  1. Peter R Reply

    I respectfully disagree with this statement. The creed is clear. Should we doubt the reference to three days? We cannot pick and choose which statements in the creed are metaphors and which ones should be taken literally. While I find it abhorent to even consider that our Lord and Savior descended into hell, perhaps that should be one of the mysteries

    1. Chris Reply

      Peter R – I agree that things that are mysteries need to stay mysteries, but let me ask this first, what is hell?

    2. Tim T Reply

      We must remember that the Creed is not in English. We get the translation of this. They are just explaining the ancient meaning of hell. We need to stop thinking of everything in our modern mindset and put ourselves in the mindset of those times.

      1. Mitch F Reply

        I agree 100 percent Tim

    3. John Reply

      my understanding is that jesus descended into the pit, and left it three days later with the keys to death

  2. Ed Layson Reply

    How do you explain Moses and Elijah meeting Jesus in the Transfiguration if they were in ‘hell’?

    1. jeri rahill Reply

      I agree Ed, How did Moses and Elijah (the Carmilites Holy One/founder) meet Jesus come up from Hades?? Also perhaps we Catholics don’t have “all” the answers; just most. After all God is God, and always mysteries! Also, there are many levels of purgatory as heaven as I recently discovered! Don’t judge, just observe!

    2. Jim Lesperance Reply

      Good question, Ed. I always thought that Jesus went there to offer everyone a chance to accept Him as the Redeemer…or not! Apparently, this says it was to gather up those who had been ‘locked out of Heaven’ waiting until Jesus defeated Satan and death.Did Elijah go up to Heaven in a “flaming Chariot”?Moses’ body was never accounted for in Scripture. Did God simply raise them up to Himself?? He’s God…He could do whatever He wanted.

      1. Lea Leger Reply

        According to scripture, Enoch and Elijah may have been assumed into heaven before the time of Jesus. In Genesis 5 v 24 says only that God ‘took him’ but doesnt say where. Sirach 44 v 16 and 49 v14 make it clear that he was taken up from the earth and Hebrews 11 v 5 adds so that he should not see death. 2 Kins 2 v 11 Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven.Both Elijah and Enoch were assumed into Heaven, but the Church teaches that heaven was not yet opened to the saints because christ has not yet come. Maybe they (Elijah, Enoch, Moses etc.) went to the abode of the dead, where the souls of the righteous were waiting for Messiah to open Heaven.Abode of the dead or she’ol is pictured in OT as being down.

  3. D. Shawver Reply

    How can unbaptized babies stay in limbo? They have not sinned. My priest told me our God is not like that, all babies shall enter the Kingdom of our Lord.

    1. Sean Anthony Aguilar Reply

      It is said that when we are born, we automatically obtained the sin made by Adam and Eve that is why we are baptized, to remove the sins we already have. Hence, if a person is not baptized, he/she still have sin, the sin that comes from Adam and Eve. 🙂 It’s my opinion only. 🙂

    2. Mitch F Reply

      They have to be cleansed from the stain of original sin created by Adam and Eve

      1. Patrick Gannon Reply

        Hmm, what “original sin” do you refer to? The RCC has accepted evolution. This does away with the Creation myth. There were no two people made of dust and ribs, no talking snakes, no fall from grace, no original sin. These things did not happen, and by accepting evolution the RCC passively accepts this. The RCC tries to explain that something must have happened in the past 200,000 years of modem man’s evolution to justify the story, but there’s no evolutionary evidence to indicate that humans once lived as one with God, and no scriptural support outside of the discounted Genesis myth.

        This whole “original sin” myth started with Paul who insisted that sin came into the world through one man, Adam – but there was no Adam. Jesus failed to tell Paul about evolution on the road to Damascus or any of the other visions. Paul was wrong. Paul was also wrong about Jesus’ imminent return. His credibility is shot.

        This is the reason that fundamentalists and many evangelicals hold fast to the Genesis story. They know that without it, there is no need to believe the right thing about Jesus in order to be saved, and they fear that people won’t be motivated to simply be “followers of Jesus” without all the fear of sin, hellfire and damnation.

        I suspect that dropping Limbo is a way to slowly lead up to the eventual dropping of original sin. The Church knows this original sin concept is nonsense, but they aren’t going to drop the myths until they absolutely have to. They too fear that Christianity can’t work without fear, but they are the masters of convoluted reasoning. It’s all falling apart now, though. No Limbo, no Exodus, no Creation myth, no original sin… no need to be saved. Where do they go from here?

    3. Edward Shadap Reply

      Now the Church has even done away with the concept of ‘Limbo’ itself. So I’m more confused why is the term still used. Also, the new ‘apostles’ creed’ says that Jesus descended to the ‘dead’. What for is not fully explained and why Jesus spent nearly three days with the ‘dead’

      1. Lea Leger Reply

        In the apostles creed did not say Jesus spent nearly 3 days with the dead, …, it says he descended to the dead and on the third day, he arose from the dead and seated at the right hand of the Father. Maybe Jesus went into hell (abode of the dead not hades) to released the righteous soul and opened the Heaven for them.

    4. Patrick Gannon Reply

      Here’s the problem the RCC has. If an aborted fetus goes straight to heaven despite not being baptized, then what harm is done? The soul goes from the starting gate to the winner’s circle and never has to run the race or roll the salvation dice. It never has to worry about being born of the wrong parents in the wrong country to the wrong religion so that it will end up in Hell. It gets to avoid all that suffering that the rest of us endure and it goes straight to heaven. Pretty good deal, huh? So the RCC can’t have that. It’s not fair. Why should that aborted fetus get to avoid all the suffering and uncertainty the rest of us must endure? It would be far better for billions upon billions of people to have been aborted, rather than go to Hell because they happen not to be Christians, if these unbaptized souls get to go to heaven.

      They avoided the problem for a long time by saying they went to Limbo. Think of how many mothers who lost their children to miscarriage or death in childbirth, were told that their offspring went to Limbo where the mother would never see them again. That strikes me as a pretty cruel and vicious thing to tell a woman who has just suffered a terrible loss.

      Now there’s no Limbo, so what happens to these souls? My understanding is that they now have a “hope” for salvation, that they didn’t have before – all as a result of decisions made by fallible men, who are now changing their minds. This “hope” for salvation is supposed to quell the anxiety of women who lose their babies before they are born – but it still sucks. They either go to Hell or they go to Heaven. If God sends them to Hell – then screw Him; I’ll gladly join them and at least know in the midst of eternal torment that I am morally superior to Him. If they go to Heaven, then what’s the harm?

      The RCC has put itself in a corner. Watch them squirm. Then remind them that the Exodus never happened, and that they have embraced evolution, which does away with the Creation myth and therefore talking snakes and original sin; and thus the need to believe, say and do the right things in order to be saved.

      How unreal is it that here we are in 2015 still worshipping mythological gods, to the benefit of powerful men in robes.

  4. Edwin L. Reply

    Are Jews who don’t believed with Jesus (as what they said that He lacked Messiahnic characteristics) will be saved? Because as what Jesus said: “Even the Pagans are welcomed to my Father’s table.” – after which the Centurion asked for Jesus to heal his servant even He is not needed to appear in his house. For the Centurion said: “I am not worthy to received you under my roof. But if you say the Word, and he shall be healed.”

  5. Nick M Reply

    Catholic Answers:

    “He didn’t, if you mean by hell the place of the damned. There would have been no purpose in his going there.

    The Apostles’ Creed contains this line in Latin: descendit ad inferos. In older English translations the word inferos was rendered as “hell,” but it was understood not to mean the place of the damned. The term actually refers to “those below”—that is, to the dead. It thus signified that he descended to visit the just who died in pre-Christian times and were waiting for heaven to be opened to them. This place is commonly called the limbo of the Fathers.

    Jesus referred to this place when he said, “As Jonah was in the whale’s belly for three days and three nights, so shall the Son of Man be in the heart of the Earth three days and three nights” (Mt 12:40).

    The expression “heart of the Earth” doesn’t mean the grave, but the underworld, what the Jews called sheol, which was thought to be located at the center of the Earth. Sheol wasn’t a place of the damned but a place of departed souls both good and bad. It appears from the parable of Lazarus and the rich man (Lk 16:19-31) that there was a place within sheol where the wicked were punished and another place where the righteous awaiting heaven were comforted. Jesus went to the latter.”

    Hope this helps!

    1. Chris Rocha Reply

      Agree

  6. Luann Chavez Reply

    Proverbs 3:5 Trust in the Lord with all your heart and lean not in your own understanding.

  7. mary ann talley Reply

    i can say is that Jesus went into hell gave those suffering souls an option come with me. are you sorry? if they were He gave them eternal life. simple the gates of heaven were closed. jESUS opened up the gates of heaven all who wanted it were forgiven.

  8. Jassi Jutt Reply

    can i ask the places where our soul goes after death ? believers and non believers soul.

    1. Lea Leger Reply

      when we die our souls will go to either Hell, Purgatory or Heaven. Those non believers or commit mortal sin and no repentant will go straight to Hell and for those believers, and died of state of grace will go to Purgatory for purification of sins then they will go to heaven. it says in the bible nothing unclean will go to heaven and we are all sinners, in order to access Heaven, we go through “cleansing fire” as stated in the Bible in order to be pure and we can go to heaven.

  9. Keith Petrvs Reply

    Disagreeing with the article slightly, does not have to specificly mean limbo. Hell in the context of the creed would have been taken from the Greek hades simply to mean place to go after death, ie afterlife. It’s very common to see, however, hades translated into hell in English

  10. Andrew Reply

    However, time does not “exist” after death.

  11. alex Reply

    which verse of the Bible that contains the quote ccc 635 above

  12. Jon Reply

    Instead of reading CCC and all that nonsense, read the Bible, the KJV and pray for God to give you wisdom and understanding

  13. Anukanti Chibueze Reply

    Jon the no nonsense person, do you even understand who king James was and the reason he translated the bible? Exactly for people like you who transcribe the bible your own way, not needing other people opinion on what who think is the truth or false. For many like you started printing many versions of self opinion. Now Jn 3:13 tells us that “No man ever ascended to heaven except the One who came from heaven, the Sun of Man”…He didn’t say He saw Elijah, Enoch, Moses or Abraham there.

  14. Ramon Reply

    Why do we ask all these questions? Isn’t our Catholic faith enough to accept and to understand this. Remember and I quote “for those who have faith, no explanation is necessary; to those who do not have faith, NO explanation is POSSIBLE.”

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories