18 Feb 2016 Articles Comments (2)

Pope Benedict Speaks to Muslims

On November 28, 2006, Pope Benedict XVI arrived in Ankara for a state visit to the Republic of Turkey. The pontiff’s visit, already a source of controversy owin…

Read more

23 Feb 2016 Articles Comments (1)

10 Tips for making the best out of the Lent Season

The Lent is a season of spiritual revival meant to elevate our awareness, worship and devotion to God. It is as well a season when we are expected to become hol…

Read more

12 Apr 2016 Vatican No comments

"Amoris Laetitia should be received with the profound respect owed to the Roman Pontiff as the Vicar of Christ" said…

Cardinal Raymond Burke says Pope Francis’s apostolic exhortation, Amoris Laetitia, was not written to change Church teaching.the cardinal said that “Pope Franci…

Read more

28 Mar 2015 Q&A No comments

Was my daughter's baptism valid?

Full Question Our first daughter lived only 20 hours. One of the nurses told me she baptized her, but I don’t know if the nurse was Catholic …

Read more

20 May 2016 Europe No comments

Polish Army brought in to help secure World Youth Day

The meeting near Krakow on July 31 has been a security headache for authorities Polish Army troops will help secure a meeting at World Youth Day between Pope F…

Read more

10 May 2016 Articles No comments

Mormonism's Baptism for the Dead

The first step toward being able to go to a Mormon temple is an interview with the "ward bishop" (roughly equivalent to a parish priest). During this interview …

Read more

11 Nov 2014 Q&A No comments

What is the Catholic understanding of the biblical plan of salvation?

Full Question I heard a radio preacher talk about the "biblical plan of salvation"--which, of course, he said the Catholic Church didn't obey. How does our…

Read more

25 Jun 2016 Articles No comments

A Plea for Priestly Penitents

Thank you for the excellent article by Jeffrey Mirus, “Three Great Lessons of the Abuse Scandal" ( July-August 2010). Dr. Mirus writes with a prophetic voice wh…

Read more

19 Sep 2014 Vatican Comments (1)

Pope Meets Jewish Leaders to Mark Rosh Hashana

Pope Francis on Wednesday afternoon met with a delegation of 40 world Jewish leaders at the Casa Santa Marta in honor of Rosh Hashana, the Jewish New Year. A…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Does the Catechism promote private interpretation of Scripture?

Full Question

According to the Catechism of the Catholic Church, “knowledge of revealed truth” is “deepened” by “theological research” and by “the intimate sense of spiritual realities which [believers] experience” (CCC 94). I thought that the magisterium was the authentic interpreter of Scripture and that private interpretation was taboo.


There is no conflict between the work of exegetes, scholars, and believers in exploring the meaning of Scripture, on the one hand, and the work of the magisterium in authentically defining the meaning of Scripture, on the other hand. Exegetes and believers must not pit their private judgment against the mind of the Church or treat their methods as the ultimate arbiters of what Scripture can or cannot mean (this is what is meant by “private interpretation”). But that doesn’t mean that ordinary Catholics and Scripture scholars cannot use their intellects to probe the meaning of Scripture. Indeed, Scripture is so rich that even when a given passage has been connected authoritatively with a certain doctrine, that does not remove that passage from the sphere of scientific or devotional inquiry. We can interpret and explore Scripture, just not in a way that contradicts what has been defined concerning it.

There is an interrelationship between the work of exegetes and believers and the work of the magisterium. It is the magisterium’s task to be the ultimate arbiter of whether or not a given theological idea belongs to the Catholic faith. But where does the theological idea come from in the first place? Who thinks of it, formulates it, develops it, expresses it? Bishops, yes, but also priests, saints, scholars, even ordinary believers. All of us, bringing our spiritual and critical faculties to the sources of faith (Scripture and Tradition) in a spirit of humility and docility to the teaching authority of the Church, may explore the meaning of divine revelation for ourselves.

Any interpretation we arrive at must not contradict what has already been defined as Catholic truth. That is why God gave the Church the power of defining things-to keep us from going wrong. We must be willing to submit our interpretations to the final judgment of the magisterium. But it would be a mistake to think that we are limited to parroting what the magisterium already has defined. That would be a recipe for crippling the ongoing development of doctrine that continually enriches our faith and unfolds the glories of that which was once for all delivered to the saints.


Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories