Follow usTwitterFacebook


03 Apr 2015 Q&A No comments

Should there be laws protecting homosexuals from discrimination in the workplace?

Full Question Should there be laws protecting homosexuals from discrimination in the workplace? Answer Genuine injustice requires correcting. If ho…

Read more

30 Jul 2016 Articles Comments (2)

There is a solution to the Islamist threat to Europe

One of the great turning points in French history occurred during the summer of 1788. One of the King’s ministers sent a note to the royal treasury, requesting …

Read more

18 Jul 2015 Articles Comments (2)

Back from the Brink

Chris and Raquel Garcia were on top of the world. They both had exciting jobs with the San Antonio Spurs. They were at the top of their game, too, rising stars …

Read more

29 Jul 2016 Americas Asia-Pacific Europe News USA Vatican Comments (1)

Heroism and sacrifice: The Catholic history of Auschwitz

Pope Francis sat quietly in one of Auschwitz's most ominous prison cells, praying in what had been the inhumane living space of St. Maximilian Kolbe, a Catholic…

Read more

08 Jun 2016 Articles Comments (4)

Are Catholics God-Makers?

In his 1999 book, Evangelical Answers – A Critique of Current Roman Catholic Apologists, Eric Svendsen claims the Catholic Church makes Mary into not just a god…

Read more

21 Jan 2016 News Vatican Comments (1)

Pope Francis changes the decree which includes 'women on Holy Thursday ritual to have their feet washed'

In many Catholic parishes on Holy Thursday, a foot washing ritual incorporated into Mass technically specifies that only men should take part because Jesus' dis…

Read more

07 Dec 2015 Americas News No comments

The three slain Priests of Peru

Fr. Miguel Tomaszek and Fr. Zbigniew Strzalkowski both from Poland, and Fr. Alessandro Dordi, from Italy who were slain in Peru by Shining Path rebels in 1991 w…

Read more

10 Jun 2016 Articles No comments

When Christianity becomes a crime

en Russia’s small Catholic community commemorated its post-communist revival this spring, it was a time to take stock of progress achieved over the past quarter…

Read more

10 Nov 2015 News Vatican Comments (1)

The Recent Vatileaks Scandal and what Pope Francis has to say

On November 4th a book titled “Via Crucis” written by Gianluigi Nuzzi was published, exposing vital and secret Vatican documentations to the entire public. This…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

If I Had A Bishop’s Ear

I’ve worked at Catholic Answers as a staff apologist since 2003. This will mark my tenth year in apologetics. Most questions I receive through letters, phone calls, email, and questions submitted to the Catholic Answers Forums and EWTN are interesting and challenging; I enjoy researching them and discovering the answers to share with people. But there is one category of questions I dread but feel compelled to answer as swiftly as possible: abuses of the Eucharist.

The most visible abuses of the Eucharist usually occur at Mass. Someone mishandles the sacred species and drops or spills occur. Someone unknown to a minister of Communion presents a pyx to be filled and takes off with the Eucharist for who-knows-what purpose. Agitators for a cause decide to make a statement about beliefs at variance with Church teaching by showing up at Mass in distinctive sashes demonstrating their devotion to their cause and their intention to present themselves for Communion anyway. Believe it or not, these abuses are mild in comparison to what happens to the Eucharistoutside the public eye–especially when the Eucharist is taken by an extraordinary minister of holy Communion to Catholics who are homebound, hospital-bound, or prison-bound.

Here are a few of the horror stories.

  • A man called to say that he had been going through his deceased mother’s home and found a stash of consecrated hosts in the cabinet, evidently stored there by someone who was distributing them to the man’s homebound mother one by one.
  • A woman whose aunt was in a nursing home contacted us about one of the visits an extraordinary minister of holy Communion had made recently to her aunt. Her aunt was unable to swallow the Eucharist placed on her tongue, so the EMHC retrieved the host and deposited it in a potted plant.
  • Another EMHC was worried about how she had handled a similar situation when she took Communion to someone at the local hospital. When the patient was unable to swallow the host, the EMHC didn’t know what to do with it. She decided to wrap the Eucharist in a tissue and throw it in the trash can in the patient’s room.

If you think this is a problem solely for laypeople handling the host, you haven’t heard the worst case yet. I consider it the worst case because it concerns a priest, who should have been trained in the proper handling of the host. When a parishioner approached this priest with a consecrated host she had found on the floor of the church, the priest advised her to burn the host and dump the ashes in a garden.

One of these days, I hope that the Lord places me in the path of a bishop and there is time to chat. If so, I will tell the bishop these horror stories and plead with him to pass on the message to his brothers in the episcopate that we desperately need more protections for the Blessed Sacrament and training for those entrusted to handle the sacred species. In all these cases, the reason our Lord suffered these indignities to his precious body, blood, soul, and divinity was ignorance, not malice. And so what is needed is knowledge, which in turn will enkindle love.

St. Tarcisius, pray for us!

By Michelle Arnold



  1. Tom Rafferty Reply

    Really, “horror stories?” A piece of unleavened bread compared to the true horrors in reality? It is amazing how silly unsupported Catholic dogma like the Transubstantiation of bread can poison the mind. Oh, before you go off on me, I was a very devout Catholic most of my 71+ years until I got out of the religious bubble. Try it.

  2. Patrick Gannon Reply

    An article like this makes me think that an all-powerful being can actually be hurt because of the way someone handles a cracker.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories