25 Sep 2015 Asia-Pacific News No comments

Report: Chinese prelates seek reconciliation with Holy See

The president and two vice presidents of China’s episcopal conference, which is not recognized by the Holy See, have traveled to the United States as part of an…

Read more

08 Dec 2015 News USA Comments (1)

U.S Christians' weak hands hurts ISIS victims

Timothy Samuel Shah, a religious freedom fighter who the associate director of the Religious Freedom Project at the Berkley Center for Religion, Peace, and Worl…

Read more

25 Jun 2015 Articles No comments

Henri de Lubac's fascinating notes on Vatican II

Introduction I’ve been wondering how to handle the decision of Ignatius Press to publish the notebooks kept by Henri de Lubac, SJ on his participation in the S…

Read more

19 Feb 2016 Articles No comments

Patriotism Begins at Home

As I leave work, I drive up a steep hill. Below me on the right are rooftops. Towering above one is a flagpole that rises a few feet above the street I use. The…

Read more

01 Dec 2015 News Vatican No comments

Pope Francis Arrive Rome and visits Marian basilica

Pope Francis arrived Rome Monday on 30th November following his six days Papal visit to Kenya, Uganda and Central African Republic. The trip to Africa marked th…

Read more

29 Oct 2014 Vatican Comments (3)

The Church's mystery: it's both visible and spiritual, Pope says

Vatican City, Oct 29, 2014 / 09:12 am .- In his weekly general audience Pope Francis spoke of the visible actions carried out by the Church, explaining that the…

Read more

11 Apr 2016 Articles Comments (3)

Why the Resurrection Was Not a Conspiracy

When confronted with the early Christians’ testimony about the Resurrection of Jesus, it is natural to question whether it’s credible. A healthy skepticism dema…

Read more

11 Dec 2014 Q&A Comments (2)

Are Catholics to believe that the cleansing fire of purgatory is real physical fire?

Full Question Are Catholics to believe that the cleansing fire of purgatory is real physical fire? Answer There are only a few propositions that …

Read more

19 Sep 2014 Vatican Comments (1)

Pope Meets Jewish Leaders to Mark Rosh Hashana

Pope Francis on Wednesday afternoon met with a delegation of 40 world Jewish leaders at the Casa Santa Marta in honor of Rosh Hashana, the Jewish New Year. A…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

If we want better bishops we must first look at our seminaries

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

Seminaries need to be replaced with a new way of training our priests

That the Catholic Church needs a better way to select Bishops is a sentiment that every Catholic, I think, could agree with. It is the headline of an article by Robert Mickens in the National Catholic Reporter, which is worth reading for the way it summarises the Pope’s recurring harsh words about bad bishops.

The Pope is a Jesuit, and in the Jesuit tradition it is normal for superiors to pronounce regular ‘exhortations’ directed at their underlings to try and knock them into shape.

In recent times words have been followed up by deeds, and several bishops have been sacked, usually for one of two reasons: financial mismanagement or sexual misconduct (sometimes, no doubt, for both). The sacking of bishops does not really solve the problem, as it is an acknowledgement that the bishops in question should never have been appointed in the first place. What one really needs is a better way of finding good bishops.

The present system essentially relies on what Italians call ‘raccomandazione’, or what we call the old boys network or cronyism. Men get made bishops because bishops recommend them for promotion; it is not what you know, but who you know.

This used to be the way of appointing civil servants to public office in Britain until Gladstone’s great reforming ministry introduced competitive examinations. Competitive examinations are, at least in theory, impartial, and an impartial system of appointments would overcome the widely perceived favouritism that disfigures the current system.

There is something of the Ancien Regime about the way the Vatican works, despite the way the Pope has railed in recent years about the leprosy of courts. Incidentally, the people who work in the Vatican, lay and clerical – how are they appointed? Are they appointed after the same sort of scrutiny used for civil servants in Whitehall and elsewhere?

One thing Mickens mentions only to discount is the election of bishops. This could work, to my mind, but it depends on who does the electing. One bishop who is elected to office is the Bishop of Rome. Conclaves have a good record of producing high quality candidates. Why not have a conclave in each diocese? It was the traditional role of canons to elect the bishop, but canons, sadly, have become more or less purely decorative in the contemporary Church, as far as I can see.

Will the Pope’s words directed at inadequate and bad bishops have any effect? Given that this problem is a perennial one, that long predates the current pontificate, I doubt it. But they certainly highlight the problem the Church faces. At the same time the Pope has spoken about the inadequacies of many priests: there perhaps the solution to the problem lies, for every bishop is drawn from the ranks of the priesthood. We certainly need better bishops, but we will never have them until we have better priests. And as priests come out of seminaries, perhaps that is where the work of reform should start.

Seminaries were established in the wake of the Council of Trent. Perhaps they have had their day and need to be replaced by some other method of training men for the priesthood which involves living in the community. Then perhaps we may have a better chance of getting pastors who, as the Pope loves to put it, “smell of the sheep".



1 comment

  1. Patrick Gannon Reply

    Hmm very interesting. I’m a bit surprised that the Church would publicly admit that its processes are essentially corrupt. From this we can conclude that Bishops are of low quality, and the Church does not operate in an ethical and efficient fashion.
    Then there’s the problem that you have a smaller and smaller pool of good people to draw from as the next generation shuns the hostility and manic sexual obsession of the Church, such that you lose them and their kids.
    There certainly appears to be no divine inspiration!

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories