08 Aug 2016 News Comments (1)

Archbishop: ‘Violent crackdown on drug crime is turning Philippines into a killing field’

Archbishop Socrates Villegas issued a statement, read in churches Sunday expressing deep concerns over the killings of drugs suspects The leader of bishops in …

Read more

13 Apr 2016 Americas Middle East News United Kingdom USA Vatican Comments (5)

Muslims gather to Honor the Virgin Mary in Lyon

During the just concluded celebration of the 'Solemnity of the Annunciation' of the Blessed Virgin Mary over 500 Muslims were found in the Maronite Catholic pa…

Read more

19 Feb 2015 Articles Comments (2)

The King's Throne

A few months ago, I wrote a blog post on the availability, or lack thereof, of sacraments for the homebound, titled Have Sacraments, Will Travel. After wr…

Read more

28 May 2016 Articles Comments (3)

Which Translation of the Bible is the Best?

Some people mistakenly think the King James Version of the Bible (KJV), with its eloquent thee’s and thou’s, is the original version.But the Bible was not wr…

Read more

13 Dec 2014 Q&A Comments (7)

I heard that praying after receiving Holy Communion is introverted. Is that true?

Full Question More than once at RCIA, I heard that praying after receiving Holy Communion is introverted. Is that true? Answer Such a statement b…

Read more

19 Dec 2015 Articles Comments (10)

Top 5 Beliefs of the Catholic Church

With mentioning, belief in God is Key and origin of all other beliefs that follow in the Catholic faith. Though the Catholic Church share most religious beliefs…

Read more

30 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

What's it like to play for the Pope? Here's how one Catholic artist described it

Performing for Pope Francis at Saturday’s Festival of Families in Philadelphia was an answer to prayer for musician Marie Miller, but getting a personal thumbs-…

Read more

19 Feb 2016 Articles No comments

Patriotism Begins at Home

As I leave work, I drive up a steep hill. Below me on the right are rooftops. Towering above one is a flagpole that rises a few feet above the street I use. The…

Read more

18 Feb 2016 Americas News Comments (3)

Pope Francis visits one time dangerous correctional facility once known as a 'center of gang power'

Pope Francis, during his visit to Cereso correctional facility on Wednesday 17th Feb, (the facility once a center of gang power and home to 3,000 prisoners), st…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Is heaven a place or only a state of mind?

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

Full Question

Recently, in our parish Bible study class, the leader stated that heaven is not a place but is in our minds, and he quoted sections 2794–2796 of the Catechism of the Catholic Church as a source for this opinion. I am deeply troubled by this concept. If heaven is not a place, then why did Jesus ascend into heaven as he left his apostles? Why would he say that he was going to prepare a “place” for them, if one did not exist? Why does the Catechism say heaven is “a way of being”? I have not been back to Bible class since this bomb was dropped on me.


Your distress shows the difficulty of expressing transcendent concepts in mere words. The truth is, we don’t know exactly what heaven is like—even if we did, we could not reduce it to language, which is a human device incapable of containing God.

Your group leader’s statement that heaven is “in our minds” is misleading, however. Heaven is within us, in the sense that each Christian is a temple of the indwelling Trinity. But it is no more accurate to say that heaven is only within us than it is to say that, by virtue of our receiving the sacraments, Jesus exists only within us. God and heaven live within us—but they also have an objective life beyond us as well.

God, in a sense, is heaven. In 1 Maccabees 3:18, for example, the author uses “Heaven” as a name for God (to avoid using the name it was forbidden to pronounce). Heaven exists wherever God is. Jesus said, “The kingdom of heaven is at hand” (Mt 4:17), meaning that, since God took on flesh, heaven itself is here, among us. After death, our experience of heaven will be to enter fully into the intimate love of the Holy Trinity, to our everlasting and perfect joy. To the extent that we participate in that love while on earth, we begin to share the joy of heaven now. Catherine of Siena said, “All the way to heaven is heaven.”

You are right that the Bible refers to “heavenly places.” We must keep in mind that time and space are finite concepts; God is not bound by them, nor could God live in one physical place, as we think of it, because the physical universe is his creation and cannot contain him. Heaven is a place, but not a particular space.

We must understand the symbolic language of the Bible and the saints as an attempt to communicate the ineffable. We do not understand literally terms such as seeing God “face to face.” We rejoice in theirmeaning: that we will be with God, intimate with him, unhindered by our mortal limitations.

As the Catechism says (section 1024), “This perfect life with the Most Holy Trinity—this communion of life and love with the Trinity, with the Virgin Mary, the angels and all the blessed—is called ‘heaven.’ Heaven is the ultimate end and fulfillment of the deepest human longings, the state of supreme, definitive happiness.”

We leave up to God “where” and “how” he fulfills his promise.


1 comment

  1. Patrick Gannon Reply

    So “heaven” is not really a place, but according to other articles in this forum, Hell is a place, right? It has to be a “place” in order for “hellfire” to do its job. There has to be real pain, and that has to happen in a place. Where is this place?

    The RCC can’t define heaven and can’t tell us the place where Hell is, yet we’re supposed to believe these things are real because of interpretations of texts written by ignorant, primitive people trying to understand the natural world, and because an organization that benefits by spreading such beliefs – particularly through indoctrination of innocent children who have not yet learned critical thinking skills, tells us that we must believe this or suffer punishment.

    The only thing we know for sure is that we do not know. I suggest that we don’t “believe” anything. Accept our ignorance rather than lie to ourselves with unfounded beliefs that lack any objective, empirical evidence whatsoever. Lying to ourselves – telling our brains we know something that the brain knows it does not know and has no evidence for, seems like it would set up a conflict in the brain. I look around the world and wonder if this internal conflict might explain why we are so screwed up as a species.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories