30 Oct 2015 Q&A Comments (1)

Does God forgive you every time you go to confession?

Answer: Yes, But ... Confession like every other sacrament has certain conditions for valid reception attached to them. For instance, before one can receive th…

Read more

09 Dec 2015 News Vatican No comments

The Environmental message of Pope Francis highlighted on the Basilica, Rome - Watch

The Year of Mercy opening ceremony in extended to the late evenings of yesterday when time came for a three hours light show of Nature and Environment. A light …

Read more

10 Apr 2015 Q&A Comments (7)

Should a priest invite non-Catholics who believe in the Real Presence to receive Communion?

Full Question During a wedding rehearsal for a Catholic and non-Catholic, the priest invited the non-Catholics to receive the Eucharist at the nuptial Mass…

Read more

13 Apr 2016 USA Comments (4)

Top Corporations in Missouri join Coalition opposing religious objections law

A coalition was joined by more than 60 businesses including some of Missouri’s biggest corporate names. The coalition opposed to state legislation that would de…

Read more

15 Mar 2016 News No comments

Ivory Coast and Turkey face terrorist attacks, Pope Francis sends his condolence

Sixteen (16) people lost their lives at the Grand-Bassam beach resort, in Ivory Coast on Sunday. Fourteen of those killed were civilians and two were soldiers, …

Read more

26 Aug 2016 Europe News USA Vatican Comments (1)

‘I can only think of our nuns’: Italian bishop criticises burkini ban

Secretary-general of the bishops' conference points out that nuns and 'peasant grandmothers' stay covered up at the beach too Bishop Nunzio Galantino, the secr…

Read more

28 Nov 2015 Middle East News No comments

Christians in Syria face suicidal choice daily: Archbishop Samir Nassa

One of Syria’s leading clerics Archbishop Samir Nassar in his pre-Christmas letter spoke of the suicidal choice which Christians in the Middle East face daily. …

Read more

19 Jan 2016 News Vatican No comments

Vatican's Monsignor Nunzio Scarano accused of money laundering cleared of corruption charges

Monsignor Nunzio Scarano, a former senior Vatican accountant accused of scheming to smuggle €20m in cash into Italy from Switzerland, in a tax evasion scheme ha…

Read more

05 Sep 2015 Articles Exhortations Family Love Doctor with GM Alimba No comments

Dear Younger Self, Here's 5 Things You Don't Need to Worry About

If I could go back and counsel my younger self, here are the top 5 Do's and Don't s I'd offer: * 1 Don't worry so much about appearances. * 2 Don't try to rai…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Is there any validity to the Fundamentalist claim that Jesus turned water into grape juice?

Full Question

Is there any validity to the Fundamentalist claim that Jesus turned water into grape juice?


None at all. They argue that “the fruit of the vine” (Matt. 26:29) is to be understood as grape juice, but there are three main problems with that notion.

First, the two common drinks in Palestine were water and wine. The phrase “fruit of the vine” meant “product of the vine.” Grape vines were grown not for grapes, but for wine.

Second, grape juice spoils quickly without refrigeration. There were very few refrigerators in Palestine at the time of Christ.

Third, at the wedding in Cana, after Christ changed water to wine, the headwaiter who tasted it said to the bridegroom, “Everyone serves good wine first, and then when people have drunk freely, an inferior one; but you have kept the good wine until now” (Jn 2:10).

Translation: Normally a host will put the good wine out first so, when people get tipsy (which you can’t do with grape juice), they won’t notice the cheap stuff later on. You, on the other hand, have saved the good stuff for last.



  1. Robert henry Reply

    All right now. Jesus turned water in Too Wine. Not grape juice. In all my years I know of no one getting drunk drinking grape juice. All so you can drink but don’t get drunk. Do a study on drinking and getting drunk.

  2. catstclair12000 Reply

    I can just hear the wine steward, “Most people serve the good grape juice first and then, when people have drunk freely, the poorer quality grape juice is served. You have saved the good grape juice for last!” Does that make any sense to anyone? It sounds like a child’s birthday party, not a wedding feast. I had to laugh when a theology teacher in a Catholic high school told me she was teaching the students that.

  3. Byron Injeeli Reply


Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories