21 Oct 2015 News USA No comments

Major evangelical group recognizes growing opposition to death penalty

The National Association of Evangelicals has issued an expanded statement on the death penalty that for the first time recognizes Christian opposition to state …

Read more

15 Dec 2015 Americas News Vatican No comments

The Holy Father officially confirms February trip to Mexico City

The Holy Father officially announced during Mass in St Peter's Basilica on Saturday 12 December, that he will be visiting Mexico City to honor Our Lady of Guada…

Read more

28 Nov 2015 Middle East - Africa News Comments (1)

Video: Watch Pope Francis' Farwell to Kenya and Arrival at Uganda - Watch

Click the "Play" button to watch Pope Francis' farewell to Kenya...   Click the "Play" button to watch…

Read more

24 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

Cardinal Sarah: efforts to 'soften' Christ's teaching ignore the Good News of mercy

Efforts to ‘soften’ Christian teaching on the family are not a solution for those wounded by sin, Cardinal Robert Sarah, a native of the west African country of…

Read more

05 Oct 2015 News Vatican No comments

Pope urges synod participants to show ‘apostolic courage and evangelical humility’

Pope Francis has spoken at the opening of the Synod of Bishops on the Family Pope Francis has called participants in the Synod of Bishops on the Family to sh…

Read more

10 Sep 2014 USA No comments

Amid mounting religious freedom threats, role of laity highlighted

Phoenix, Ariz., Sep 10, 2014 / 04:35 am .- As domestic religious freedom threats reach unprecedented levels, the lay faithful must play an active role in promot…

Read more

02 Apr 2015 Q&A No comments

If St. Maximilian Kolbe offered his life to save a fellow prisoner, was he truly a martyr?

Full Question St. Maximilian Kolbe (1894-1941) died in Auschwitz when he offered to take the place of another man being sent with a group of prisoners to d…

Read more

05 Feb 2016 Articles No comments

A Rabbi Led Me to Rome

A priest and a rabbi walk into a hospital . . . It sounds like the opening of a joke, but that moment marks the beginning of my journey toward the Catholic…

Read more

10 Jun 2015 Exhortations Resources No comments

Philippines bishops urge voters to reject ‘corrupt’ politicians in 2016

Catholic bishops in the Philippines have urged voters to reject “notoriously corrupt" politicians running in next year’s national elections. In a pastoral le…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

‘Judge Not’ Doesn’t Mean Don’t Make Judgments

If I had been the Holy Spirit’s editor when he was inspiring the Bible, I would have recommended that he not include that New Testament verse where Jesus says, “Judge not, that you be not judged" (Matt. 7:1). Better still, I would have recommended keeping the verse but adding a clarifying commentary so that it could not be misused by American moral liberals of the late twentieth and early twenty-first centuries. I would have had Jesus speak a few more words, beginning with, “Please, don’t misunderstand me . . ."

Moral liberals—I mean the kind of people who believe, among other things, in sexual freedom, abortion, and same-sex marriage—have been preaching an ethic of non-judgmentalism for more than a half century now, and they have won vast numbers of converts. According to this ethic, we must tolerate all attitudes and behaviors that do no direct, obvious, and tangible harm—harm to others, that is.

It’s your life

For if you are eighteen years of age or older, and you wish to do things or think things or feel things that harm yourself, well, that’s up to you. You are the owner of yourself. It’s your life, your body, your mind. You are free to do what you like with your own property as long as you don’t hurt your neighbor.

As a result of this ethic of non-judgmentalism, we Americans have learned to tolerate a great deal of bad morals, bad manners, bad music, vulgarity, profanity, obscenity, pornography, blasphemy, etc. The two most recent achievements along this line have to do with our latest metaphysical fad, transgenderism. Americans are now expected to abstain from judging that you’re mistaken or even mentally ill if you believe that you’re a man in a woman’s body or a woman in a man’s body.

We even tolerate—and, if we are thoroughgoing liberals, we applaud—reckless parents who encourage their seven-year-old boy to believe he is a girl. We are quickly learning to have no objection when a man uses a women’s restroom or a woman uses a men’s restroom.

Three kinds of non-judgers

I have known three kinds of people who contend that the “Judge not" statement of Jesus is an endorsement of something like the liberal spirit of tolerance. One kind is made up of non-Christians. People of this kind are religious skeptics (atheists or agnostics) who never read the Bible, not even as literature. Yet on this particular issue they claim to understand the mind of Jesus better than do Christians.

A second kind is just barely Christian (or should I say “Christian"?). Intellectually they dwell in the suburbs of atheism, but they are not quite ready to move downtown. They hesitate to completely renounce the Christianity they embraced, or semi-embraced, in their childhood. And so, while being moral liberals, they are happy to persuade themselves that Jesus, were he so fortunate as to be living in the USA in the twenty-first century, would give his stamp of approval (with perhaps a few minor qualifications) to sexual freedom, abortion, and same-sex marriage. It is easy to understand that Christians of this modernistic kind are delighted when they remember this “Judge not" dictum of the New Testament.

A third kind are genuine Christians who honestly misunderstand what Jesus meant. People of this kind allow that it’s okay to make negative judgments regarding external behavior, but they insist that we must abstain from judging internal motives. We may say that a man did a bad thing, but we mustn’t say that he’s a bad man. Only God can judge the heart.

We judge all the time

There is, of course, a sense in which this is true. God alone can judge the value of a person’s whole life. Only God, viewing both the inner and outer man, can say, “Hitler was a good person" or “Hitler was a bad person." But as for the motives and intentions of this particular moment or this particular day, anybody may judge. Judges and juries make these judgments every day all over the world. And so do you and I in our routine interactions with other people.

But because people of the third kind, these good Christians, are so reluctant to make negative judgments, they give aid and comfort to the two other kinds mentioned above.

When we don’t use a skill, even a skill that was once highly developed in us, the skill gets rusty; it atrophies. You used to play a lot of tennis; you haven’t played in a number of years, and now you find that you’re not very good at tennis anymore. So is it with making value judgments. Americans, due to a half-century or more of non-use, have grown unskilled at making sound value judgments.

Written By David Carlin



  1. Tom Rafferty Reply

    Since there is no legitimate outside organization to determine morality, and evolution has given humanity reason, empathy and cooperation, what is wrong with the principle of simply do no harm? This piece is full of ignorance and bigotry toward those who’s sex or gender may be different from the majority. A little research shows that these areas of humanity, as well as other mammals, fall on a continuum and are not binary male and female.

  2. Patrick Gannon Reply

    “Americans are now expected to abstain from judging that you’re mistaken or even mentally ill if you believe that you’re a man in a woman’s body or a woman in a man’s body.”
    How about, “Americans are expected to abstain from judging that you’re mistaken or even mentally ill if you believe in talking snakes and donkeys, that the sun stopping in the sky without anyone flying off the earth, walking on water, turning water to wine, virgin births, being raised from the dead, etc.” If only one person said these fantastical things, we’d surely think him or her insane and lock them up, but when 2 billion people say these fantastical things, we call it religion, and they say we’re not permitted to question the outrageous beliefs of these people. Those days are over.
    “People of this kind are religious skeptics (atheists or agnostics) who never read the Bible, not even as literature.”
    Whoa. A higher percentage of atheists and agnostics read the bible, than believers. That’s often what turns them away from the religion.
    Note the real message here. The author wants justification for his bigotry and is distressed that Jesus actually spoke against such attitudes: “If I had been the Holy Spirit’s editor when he was inspiring the Bible, I would have recommended that he not include that New Testament verse where Jesus says, “Judge not, that you be not judged" (Matt. 7:1).” But those things are in the book and you are telling Catholics to ignore the words of Jesus in order to satiate your hunger for hostility to the other that so defines Christianity today.
    I am confused. We have a Pope who is trying to put some “lipstick on the pig” and make Catholicism less hostile, but as we can see in this and similar articles, he’s not making any real progress.
    Keep it up. The young are leaving in droves.

    1. Rachael Reply

      Yay, Patrick! I was just about to reply with very similar comments….especially to point out that a much higher percent of atheists than Christians have actually read the bible.
      Also note, the author never explains what “the Holy Spirit” really meant by the ‘judge not’ quote. He simply asserts that we shouldn’t “misunderstand.” So ridiculous.

  3. Antonio Reply

    How can You quote a message of love and acceptance for all human brings and then proceed to offer a completely contradictory viewpoint even going so far as to judge those who “arent Christian enough” as if your religion is a game of earning Little points from god whenever you chastise a sinner. The very point of that line is to Illustrate to people that You should Be more concerned in your own righteousness then în making those around You feel like crap about themselves.

  4. Steve Liedy Reply

    A valid criticism above. You might consider amending this article with an explanation of what Jesus did mean. And did you feel as uneasy as I did with your insinuation that the Holy Spirit did a poor job inspiring scripture?

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories