28 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (2)

Is my friend's theory that God created more than one set of first parents heretical?

Full Question A friend told me that God created other "parents" besides Adam and Eve, including Cain's wife. Is this heretical? Answer Your frien…

Read more

31 Jul 2016 News No comments

‘Go out into the world,’ Pope tells priests at St John Paul II shrine

Francis celebrated Mass at a shrine dedicated to his Polish predecessor Catholic priests and nuns must renounce their personal interests and create a church th…

Read more

23 Aug 2016 Articles No comments

The price of war: Child victims ignored in fight for power

The air is thick with dust and the ground is littered with debris. Buildings are crumbling and the sound of warplanes no longer send Syria's people running. …

Read more

05 Feb 2016 News USA Vatican Comments (1)

Fake Catholic Priest exposed in L. A

Erwin Mena have been posing as a Catholic priest at St. Ignatius of Loyola parish in Highland Park, in a visit to cover for the original Parish who was on vacat…

Read more

27 Aug 2016 Uncategorized Comments (1)

If the minister has no access to a sacristy, what should be done with a host that has been spit…

Full Question My understanding is that hosts that have been spit out by a communicant who is unable to swallow must be dissolved in water and then the wate…

Read more

23 Sep 2014 USA No comments

Criticism of abortion funding in health care law spans party lines

Washington D.C., Sep 23, 2014 / 12:34 am .- Pro-life Republicans and Democrats alike have voiced condemnation for the findings of a recent report showing that f…

Read more

13 Oct 2015 News Vatican No comments

Cardinal Dolan reportedly among concerned bishops who wrote Pope about synod

New York's archbishop is listed among the signatories in a letter last week to Pope Francis over whether this year's Synod on the Family lacked the “openness an…

Read more

20 May 2016 Articles Comments (4)

It May Be Real for You, but Not for Me

If you haven’t seen “College Kids Say the Darndest Things," a recent video released by the Family Policy Institute of Washington (FPIW), check it out. You will …

Read more

24 Jun 2015 Exhortations Resources Vatican No comments

Pope Francis speaks up for Italy's unemployed youth

Youth unemployment is “a true social plague" that leaves young people feeling useless, Pope Francis told an Italian labor group on Saturday. “The human being…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Luther affirmed Mary’s perpetual virginity. It’s a shame that many Protestants now reject it

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

The Reformers understood that Mary’s status protects Christian beliefs about Jesus

Which famous theologian wrote the following?

I firmly believe that Mary, according to the words of the Gospel as a pure Virgin, brought forth for us the Son of God, and in childbirth and after childbirth forever remained a pure, intact Virgin.

No, it’s not from St Louis de Montfort’s True Devotion to Mary. It’s from the writings of Ulrich Zwingli – perhaps the most extreme of the 16th-century Protestant Reformers.

Zwingli isn’t the only Reformer to have affirmed traditional Christian teaching on Mary’s perpetual virginity. Luther defended the dogma after being excommunicated. Calvin is more difficult to pin down. He mocked the idea that Mary took a vow of virginity as “barbarous tyranny," but rejected the view that Mary had other children after the birth of Jesus in equally strident terms as “excessive ignorance".

Bishop Hugh Latimer – a staunch Protestant burned at the stake by Queen Mary – goes to great lengths in his St Stephen’s Day Sermon of 1552 to rebut the arguments of those who reject Mary’s perpetual virginity, blasting them as “heretics" who “violate, toss, and turmoil the Scriptures of God, according to their own fantasies and foolish minds." In a letter to a Catholic in 1749, Methodist founder John Wesley – himself an Anglican priest – professed his belief that Mary “as well after as before she brought [Christ] forth, continued a pure and unspotted virgin."

With this in mind, it is intriguing to see how universally – and often how vociferously – ancient Christian teaching on Mary is rejected by most evangelical Protestants today.

A typical example comes from respected Presbyterian scholar Peter Leithart, who has just published a robust attack on the doctrine of Mary’s perpetual virginity at First Things.

Leithart claims that that when the Gospels say Joseph did not have relations with Mary “until she had borne a son" (Matt 1:25), this implies the couple did have marital relations after she gave birth.

To understand why this view is mistaken, Leithart need only have consulted the footnotes of the classic Protestant Geneva Bible published in 1560, in which the translators note that the word “until" is not an indication that something different happened afterward. When Jesus says, “I am with you always, until the end of the world" (Matt 28:20), obviously this does not mean he ceases to be with us in the afterlife.

Leithart claims that Joseph did not have sex with Mary during her pregnancy because the temporary presence of Jesus within her body rendered it holy, like the Temple in the Old Testament. After this, however, she “reverted to ‘common’ status."

But this is to overlook what the Trinity teaches us about what it means to be a person – that who we are as persons is defined, in part, by the relationship we have to other persons. Mother of God (Theotokos) – the relationality that Mary had to Jesus – was not a function she performed for a period of time, like an incubating machine. It was part of who Mary was as a person, and who she was always destined to be.

The Council of Ephesus in 431 reaffirmed Mary’s traditional title of Mother of God, not for the sake of her own honour but to rebut Nestorianism, a bizarre Christological heresy which claimed that Jesus, while one individual, was two persons (one human and one divine). Ancient Marian teachings all serve a similar function, protecting the integrity of what Christians believe about Jesus.

Where Mary’s role in the economy of salvation is denigrated, the result is not greater focus on Christ, but a re-emergence of ancient Christological heresies, as seen in Protestant churches during the nineteenth and twentieth centuries (Catholicism has been remarkably free of this tendency, despite ongoing theological crises since the 1960s). The Protestant Reformers realised this connection. That’s why, as historian Sir Diarmaid MacCulloch notes, they treated Mary with “reverence and affection" as a “guarantee of the Incarnation of Christ."

In today’s world, the doctrine of Mary’s perpetual virginity reminds us of our eternal destiny in relationship to Jesus.

Sex within marriage is good and holy. But celibacy – or perpetual virginity – is in a very specific and limited sense, a more perfect state. It is not morally better. Consecrated virgins are not making a more ethical lifestyle choice. But it is more perfect in an eschatological sense, because total consecration to God comes nearer to the state towards which we are journeying in the afterlife, where “they neither marry nor are given in marriage" (Matt 22:30).

Yet Mary had already attained perfect union with God, and the Promised Land toward which we are currently all on a journey, was contained in her womb. That is why, as St Ephraim says, the ever-virgin Mary is a “heaven for us."



1 comment

  1. Peter Aiello Reply

    If Mary was a perpetual virgin, it means that she did not consummate her marriage to Joseph. In Judaism, does this mean that she was not really married to Joseph and that they only lived together?

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories