28 Aug 2016 Articles Comments (1)


On Wednesday, April 23, a friend came over, distraught, saying his father had a heart attack or something and they are med-flighting him from Eau Clare, WI to S…

Read more

10 Oct 2016 News No comments

Haitians worship amid devastation caused by hurricane

Haitian Christians gathered for worship on Sunday despite devastation of Hurricane Matthew Survivors of Hurricane Matthew put on their Sunday finest and picked…

Read more

26 May 2016 Vatican No comments

Key passages in Amoris Laetitia recycle article by Argentine ‘ghostwriter’, claims blogger

Controversial passages of the exhortation follow previous writings by Archbishop Victor Manuel Fernández New questions have been raised about Pope Francis’s ap…

Read more

22 Mar 2016 Europe News No comments

Pope expresses his prayerful solidarity with victims of the Istanbul Saturday tragedy

Pope Francis has expressed his sadness over Saturday’s bombing in central Istanbul which left at least four dead and some 36 others injured. He expressed his…

Read more

09 Dec 2016 News No comments

Beautiful tradition celebrates the Immaculate Conception of the Blessed Virgin Mary

Every December for the past five years, a pilgrimage of 400 riders on horseback travels to the Shrine of Our Lady of Guadalupe At the Shrine, pilgrims offer …

Read more

10 Jun 2016 Americas Asia-Pacific Australia Europe News United Kingdom USA Vatican Comments (1)

Vatican officials to attend Pan-Orthodox Council on Pope Francis' orders

Pope Francis will send high-level observers to the pan-Orthodox council meeting in Crete as a gesture of support for the Orthodox Church. The Holy and Great …

Read more

08 Aug 2016 Q&A No comments

Is it required that the bodily remains or cremains be present at a Catholic funeral?

Full Question Is it required that the bodily remains or cremains be present at a Catholic funeral? Answer No, but it is good for the remains to…

Read more

02 Nov 2014 Articles No comments

Augustine’s Confessions and the Harmony of Faith and Reason

The history of Colonial England in America is one of great irony: The same Protestant groups who fled England in pursuit of toleration and religious liberty bro…

Read more

18 Jul 2015 Articles No comments

St. Thérèse of Lisieux

St. Thérèse of Lisieux Feast Day: October 1st The youngest daughter of a watchmaker, Thérèse wrote that her earliest childhood memories were filled with “sm…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Moving too fast on divorce question could lead to fracture, Kurtz says

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

The two most senior officials of the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops are Archbishop Joseph Kurtz of Louisville, Kentucky, the body’s president, and Cardinal Daniel DiNardo of Galveston-Houston, Texas, the vice president. Both are elected delegates to the Oct. 4-25 Synod of Bishops on the family, and today Crux presents interviews with both men about their perceptions of the event.

ROME — If bishops around the world applied the teachings of the Church differently — for example, some letting remarried Catholics receive Communion and others refusing — it could lead to a “fracture" in the Church, according to the leading US bishop at the summit.

Louisville Archbishop Joseph Kurtz, head of the US Conference of Catholic Bishops and a synod delegate, has a request for his fellow prelates who are considering kicking thorny pastoral decisions to the local level: Please slow down.

If individual countries varied on how they deal with key issues, Kurtz worries that global communion is at risk.

“Naturally, it’s obvious to people that if it’s a topic that relates to the unity of Church teaching, I think it would fracture communion," he said.

He said the so-called Kasper proposal, an idea floated by German Cardinal Walter Kasper to create a pathway for Catholics who are divorced and remarried to be readmitted to Communion on a case-by-case basis, demands much more theological reflection before being adopted.

Kurtz, who spoke with Crux Friday at the North American College, a seminary for Americans studying in Rome, also addressed the issue of infighting among some bishops, even in the public arena.

Last week, for example, Philadelphia Archbishop Charles J. Chaput wrote that a sense of anxiety about the synod’s final report has permeated the summit, while Chicago Archbishop Blase Cupich said that Pope Francis looked to be at peace, so other bishops should be as well.

Kurtz placed himself somewhere in the middle.

“I think there is unity within the synod, but there are a diversity of opinions that are being suggested," he said.

(Cupich also made comments during his press briefing Friday thatsome commentators interpreted as support for the rights of individual believers to follow their consciences when deciding if they should receive Communion, even if it goes against Church law, an idea Chaput rejected in another interview published Monday.)

The day after Kurtz spoke to Crux, Pope Francis gave an address in which he called on national conferences to play a greater role in the life of the Church.

Kelly Gissendaner executed in Georgia
Despite pope’s appeal, Ga. parole board denies murderer’s 11th-hour clemency bid
Although he leads one of those national conferences that would presumably be tasked with crafting pastoral responses should that proposal move forward, Kurtz questioned if they are even the right venues for such conversations.

There are two levels of authority, he said, “the universal Church and the local church, and the local church is really the diocese."

Early in the synod process, some cardinals, including two Americans, expressed concern about the synod’s structure, sending a letter to Pope Francis that leaked to the press. Kurtz said he wasn’t aware of the letter at the time, and when asked how he felt about the new process, he said, “I love it."

“I love the fact that when there is a topic [to discuss], we hear from the [full group], we have free exchange, but then very quickly we go into the small groups, where I think the real roll-up-the-sleeves work is done," he said.

Some Catholics have expressed high hopes for dramatic changes in how bishops apply Church teaching, while others have warned of schism should reforms be seen as too liberal.

But during a press briefing Friday, Anglican Bishop Timothy Thorton, a non-voting synod observer, said he does not foresee any dramatic action at the meeting’s conclusion — a view shared by Kurtz.

“The sense I have within the body of the synod delegates is that there’s not a desire to precipitously move on a dramatic change without thinking through what are both the short-term and long-term effects," he said.

But, he said, any decisions lie ultimately with the pope, noting that Francis himself has pointed out that the synod is an advisory body. “It’s not a parliament that’s voting on legislation," Kurtz said.

The pope emphasized this point, too, during his Saturday address, saying, “the synodal process culminates in listening to the Bishop of Rome, called upon to speak authoritatively as ‘shepherd and teacher of all Christians.’"

Regardless of how long it takes for the pope to offer changes in pastoral practices, if ever, Kurtz said he plans to bring back to his archdiocese important lessons from the synod immediately.

“I think there are going to be some very positive, immediate effects that come from the conversations we’ve had on language, on best practices, on the need to support families, that they might inspire one another," he said. “These are themes that have gone right through the synod, and they’re things I’ll carry home with me that I’ll do pastorally, even before there’s any formal action."

By Michael O’Loughlin


1 comment

  1. larry Reply

    The Pope ,the Vicar of Christ, is filled with the holy spirit. He is the head of the Church of Christ, what the Pope says and does must not be questioned. The synod is not a democratic parliament, they can voice their opinions but not lead or dissent. To do so is to question Jesus and G-D. What the Bishops need to do is consecrate Russia, by her name, by name, to the sacred heart of the Virgin Mary of Fatima. Do It without fear or consequences of those who do not want good to overcome evil…..

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories