Follow usTwitterFacebook


02 May 2016 Asia-Pacific No comments

Indian bishop released after being kidnapped and assaulted by unknown attackers requesting for money

Bishop Prasad Gallela of Cuddapah was blindfolded, handcuffed and abducted shortly after celebrating Mass A Catholic bishop in southern India was kidnapped and…

Read more

21 Nov 2014 Q&A No comments

Is marrying a relative allowed by the Church?

Full Question Is marrying a relative allowed by the Church? Answer Consanguinity in the direct line (e.g., father-daughter, grandmother-grand…

Read more

20 Aug 2015 Uncategorized No comments

Slovakia ‘will only accept Christian refugees’

Eastern European countries faces EU and UN criticism Slovakia says it will only accept Christian refugees once it takes in Syrians under an EU relocation schem…

Read more

29 Oct 2015 Europe News No comments

Archbishop Tartaglia again on the government over Tax cuts

Archbishop Philip Tartaglia, the president of the Scottish Bishops’ Conference who last month attacked the British government with his words calling them “mean …

Read more

03 Oct 2015 News Vatican No comments

The Vatican must speak on conscientious objection

For as long as anyone can remember, the Vatican has had a special genius for snatching public relations defeat from the jaws of victory. Even by that standard, …

Read more

02 Nov 2016 News Comments (1)

Satanists don’t believe in Satan, says Satanic leader

Lucien Greaves said their priorities were personal autonomy and scientific rationalism Satanism is on the increase – but Satanists don’t actually believe in Sa…

Read more

04 Nov 2016 News Comments (1)

Catholic Church will never ordain women priests, says Pope Francis

Francis discussed the ordination of women, refugees and the Venezuela crisis during his latest in-flight press conference The Catholic Church’s insistence that…

Read more

13 Dec 2014 Q&A Comments (7)

I heard that praying after receiving Holy Communion is introverted. Is that true?

Full Question More than once at RCIA, I heard that praying after receiving Holy Communion is introverted. Is that true? Answer Such a statement b…

Read more

21 Sep 2015 Americas News No comments

In Cuba, Pope Francis urges youth to hope and dream for the future

Pope Francis set aside his prepared remarks to respond to the dreams and hopes of young people who spoke to him in Cuba on Sunday evening. “I took notes,” he…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Not winning the Nobel won’t affect Francis as a ‘Peace Pope.’

ROME — Pope Francis has once again been passed over for the Nobel Peace Prize; it went to a quartet of Tunisian organizations that held the country together when it was on the brink of civil war in 2013. But the obvious question is what difference it will make – to the pontiff personally, to the Vatican, and to Francis’ capacity to act as a ‘Peace Pope.’

With no disrespect to the Nobel committee, the most honest answer is probably that it makes precious little difference at all.

First of all, one purpose of bestowing such honors is generally to give a boost to someone trying to do good who may be struggling to find either the means or the visibility to carry forward their cause.

If there’s anyone on the planet who really doesn’t need help attracting interest, it’s probably Pope Francis, who, according to most surveys, is already one of the most easily recognized and beloved public figures in the world.

(Of course, at times it works the other way, with the Peace Prize seemingly almost a ratification of someone’s celebrity status rather than their actual accomplishments. Many saw the 2009 award to US President Barack Obama in that light. Francis doesn’t need that kind of affirmation either.)

Another side effect of winning the Nobel Prize is to transform someone into an acknowledged moral authority, with the political credibility and internationally recognized gravitas to be taken seriously.


Being elected pope pretty much covers that one.

To use the language made famous by Harvard political scientist Joseph Nye, the Vatican is already the world’s most important “soft power,” the only major world religion with its own sovereign status and diplomatic corps. The Vatican has always aspired to be a voice of conscience in global affairs, and has an established bully pulpit with which to do so.

Moreover, a pope by definition is the leader of a global faith community with 1.2 billion followers scattered in every nook and cranny of the planet, and therefore someone whose social and political agenda is always going to be taken seriously.

On the other hand, one could argue that the pope winning the Nobel Prize would have marked something of a rapprochement with secular opinion, since for a long stretch of the John Paul II years there was an informal veto on honoring the pontiff because of Catholicism’s stands on controversial issues such as contraception.

Once again, however, Francis doesn’t really need an assist in that regard. He’s already become a phenomenon outside the Church, and is seen as someone open to dialogue even with people who reject some aspects of Catholic doctrine.

Finally, there’s also little evidence that Francis needs the Nobel committee to boost his effectiveness as a peacemaker.


Pope Francis again a top contender for the Nobel Peace Prize
The pontiff has already paved the way for healing the Cold War tensions between the United States and Cuba, and he’s also revealed that he’s taken a personal interest in peace talks to end Colombia’s long-standing civil war, having spoken twice by phone to President Juan Manuel Santos.

Next month he’ll be in the Central African Republic, where he has the chance to help resolve that nation’s bloody conflict — in part, perhaps, by calling on Christian militias to stop carrying out reprisal attacks on the Muslim minority.

Francis has often said he believes there’s a Third World War being fought today in piecemeal fashion. He’s shown himself to be an effective piecemeal troubleshooter, hopping from one conflict zone to the next, either in person or at a distance.

Going forward, it’s likely that any time a new conflict erupts around the world, someone will suggest asking the pope to intervene. It’s hard to imagine that having a Nobel Prize on his résumé would give him credibility he otherwise couldn’t obtain – although, of course, it certainly wouldn’t hurt.

None of this is to suggest that were he eventually to win the award, Francis would spurn it impolitely. He’d be gracious, although on background, Vatican officials say it’s doubtful that he would travel to Oslo to accept. He generally declines such personal honors, and would donate any prize money to charity.

In any event, in the pontiff’s case, winning the Nobel Peace Prize would be less about opening new doors than about recognizing those through which he’s already walked.

Perhaps the real impact of seeing the Nobel Peace Prize go to Francis would be less on the pope himself or the institution he leads, and more on the rest of the world.

It would be a potent reminder that even in a highly secular age in which institutional religion appears to be in decline, a pope skilled at deploying his spiritual and moral authority — one who, to use the phrase made popular in the John Paul years, “knows how to pope” — can still change history.

By John L. Allen Jr.


Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories