Follow usTwitterFacebook


07 Dec 2014 Q&A No comments

Are all sins equally offensive to God?

Full Question Aren't all sins equally offensive to God? After all, James 2:10 says, "For whoever keeps the whole law but fails in one point has become guil…

Read more

18 Oct 2014 Q&A Comments (12)

Do Catholics believe in the Rapture?

The dead in Christ will rise first; then we who are alive, who are left, shall be caught up together with them in the clouds to meet the Lord in the air; and so…

Read more

12 Dec 2014 Q&A Comments (13)

Does the Church excuse people from Sunday Mass obligation based on their age?

Full Question My elderly mother was told that when you reach your golden years you are excused from attending Sunday Mass. Does the Catholic Church excuse …

Read more

10 Oct 2016 News No comments

Pope Francis names 17 new cardinals

Thirteen cardinals - including three Americans - are eligible to vote in a conclave Pope Francis named 17 new cardinals Sunday from Asia, Africa, North and Sou…

Read more

25 Aug 2016 Uncategorized Comments (2)

May a couple who marry in the Church, divorce, and later reconcile resume marital relations?

Full Question A husband and wife are validly married in the Catholic Church, and after several years get a civil divorce, never seek an annulment, live cha…

Read more

16 Mar 2015 Q&A Comments (2)

Is it sinful to buy a blessed rosary?

Full Question I have always liked old rosaries and have over the years bought many rosaries at various places. I have never re-sold any rosary I have bough…

Read more

12 Sep 2016 Uncategorized Comments (1)

The heart of Padre Pio is coming to Boston. Yes, really.

The Capuchin keepers of the relics of the late mystic Padre Pio are sending the saint’s heart to Boston for his feast day. "I'm very excited to announce that…

Read more

24 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

As it happened: canonisation of Blessed Junipero Serra

Pope Francis is celebrating Mass for the Canonisation of Blessed Junipero Serra Source: http://www.catholicheral…

Read more

02 Jan 2017 News No comments

Order of Malta leader professes loyalty to Pope Francis amid Vatican investigation

Fra' Matthew Festing said the Order would follow the Pope at this 'complex and difficult time' The leader of the Order of Malta has promised Pope Francis his l…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Patriotism Begins at Home

As I leave work, I drive up a steep hill. Below me on the right are rooftops. Towering above one is a flagpole that rises a few feet above the street I use. The flagpole sports two flags, the Stars and Stripes and the first Navy jack. The latter has 13 red and white stripes, a stretched-out timber rattlesnake, and the words Don’t Tread on Me.
Sometimes I’m tempted to drive down the hill, find the owner of the flagpole, and puckishly ask him why he flies these flags so prominently. I expect him to answer, “Because I want to show my patriotism.”

“But are you really showing your patriotism—or is it your nationalism?”

“They’re the same thing.”

“No, they’re not. They’re different, and one is good while the other isn’t.”

At this point in my fantasy he guffaws and tells me to get lost.

But it’s a point worth making, particularly as we approach elections and can expect to see a superfluity of flags and bunting. There is a difference between patriotism and nationalism, and it’s one that eludes many Catholics.

Patriotism is the love of one’s native or adopted place, simply for what it is—not because it is “the best in the world” (whatever that means), not because it is the “richest,” not because it is the “most powerful.” All such considerations are irrelevant to patriotism. Someone living in a politically backward country that is poor and that “projects” no power beyond its own borders can be every bit as patriotic as an American. He can love his place and his people as much as Americans love theirs.

We tend to think of patriotism as being only a country-level thing: Someone’s a “patriotic American,” and that’s the end of it. But “patriotism”—which stems from the Latin patria, meaning “fatherland” or “homeland”—starts at home. The virtue of patriotism (and it is a virtue) begins at home and works outward: neighborhood, town, county, state, region, country. You can’t very well say you love the place that is America without first loving particular places withinAmerica. It’s as though you say you love Americans in general but not any American in particular.

Patriotism, being a species of love, is a good thing. It needs to be contrasted with nationalism, which arises not out of love but out of pride. We know that pride is a sin—the chief of the Seven Deadlies—but colloquially we use the word pride in positive senses: I have pride in my child’s educational attainments; I have pride in my favorite sports teams; I have pride in what my co-workers accomplish at the office.

The pride that underlies nationalism is not this harmless sort. The nationalist thinks America is “the best,” that Americans are “the best,” that American politics and culture are of universal applicability. His fundamental attitude is not one of gratitude and satisfaction but of expansion and even imposition. There is no room for foreigners to be equally nationalistic because their countries and their people are not “the best.” They are inferior in history or constitution or military power or table manners.

Woodrow Wilson said, “The world must be made safe for democracy”—another way of saying, “The world needs to be remade in our own image, even if this remaking needs to be imposed upon it.” In its extreme form, this idea inspired Napoleon and Hitler and Stalin, each of whom, out of ideology mixed with nationalism, sought to remake the world. In its mild form, this idea is still subversive. This should not surprise a Catholic. Just as pride differs from love, so nationalism differs from patriotism. Just as a Catholic should avoid pride and foster love, so he should avoid nationalism and foster patriotism.

By: Karl Keating


Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories