04 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (43)

How can I show that Jehovah's Witnesses are wrong about birthday celebrations?

Full Question My wife is studying with Jehovah's Witnesses, and they have convinced her that celebrating birthdays is a pagan custom and not something Chri…

Read more

25 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

Our brother, the Pope – Bishop Conley on the papal visit thus far

Bishop James Conley says that Pope Francis' mandate to go beyond the narrow confines of own worlds is a challenge, but not one without encouragement from their …

Read more

16 Oct 2015 Asia-Pacific News No comments

Caritas Pakistan marks 50 years of service in South Asia

Hundreds of Catholics in Pakistan gathered last month for a Mass of Thanksgiving which kicked off celebrations of the 50th anniversary of the foundation of Cari…

Read more

27 Jan 2015 Q&A Comments (3)

Why have English-speaking Protestant countries been blessed with freedom and prosperity, if they are out of favor with God?

Full Question If the Reformation was a rebellion, why has God blessed the English-speaking, Protestant countries with more freedom and prosperity than the …

Read more

28 Apr 2016 News No comments

Amoris Laetitia footnote contradicts Church’s tradition, says leading German philosopher

Robert Spaemann said Communion was a 'yes or no' question and that the Pope's document could lead to a schism Robert Spaemann, one of the foremost living Catho…

Read more

19 Nov 2016 Articles Comments (1)

Have we got the Ten Commandments wrong? Why does this ancient copy look different from what we've been taught?

Wait, what? The Ten Commandments have another commandment? The oldest known surviving stone tablet of the Ten Commandments has been auctioned off in California.…

Read more

21 Oct 2015 News Vatican Comments (2)

Fundraising campaign launched to promote Cause of John Paul I

'He was for a poor Church long before Pope Francis,' says campaign founder A group has launched The Pope John Paul I Association, a fundraising campaign to “…

Read more

03 Oct 2016 News No comments

Canadian cardinal won’t refuse funerals for those choosing assisted suicide

Cardinal Gerald Lacroix of Quebec said he would not follow in the steps of other Canadian bishops Cardinal Gerald Lacroix of Quebec said he has no intention to…

Read more

04 Nov 2016 News No comments

ISIS leader Al-Baghdadi may be captured in Mosul, orders men to fight to the death

Abu Bakr Al-Baghdadi is ordering his men to fight to the death in Mosul. Suicide bombers and lone wolves have been encouraged to attack. It's the kind of orders…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Pope Francis comments on Amoris Laetitia, but did he respond to his cardinals?

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

Pope Francis has made a statement about his letter, Amoris Laetitia, suggesting some people may not fully understand the document and need more time. The comment comes after four cardinals asked the Pope to clarify their understanding of the document.

Last September, four cardinals sent a letter to Pope Francis asking him to clarify some of his words in Amoris Laetitia. Cardinals Raymond Burke, Carlo Caffarra, Walter Brandmüller and Joachim Meisner sent Pope Francis five questions. The questions can be answered in a yes or no format.

But Pope Francis is not under any obligation to reply to the letter. The Cardinals have suggested if Pope Francis does not reply, they can meet, discuss and issue a correction. This is true.

Now, in an interview published today in the Italian newspaper Avvenire, Pope Francis is quoted as saying that some people see things with “a certain legalism” and “The Council told us this, but historians say that a century needs to pass before a Council is properly assimilated into the body of the Church. we are half way.” Pope Francis was referring to the council that produced the conclusions written into Amoris Laetitia.

Ultimately, the four Cardinals have questions about moral law and who may receive Communion and under which circumstances.

There seems to be a large number of people who are shocked and surprised that some of the clergy would send a letter to the pope asking for clarification, and saying they might issue a corrective commentary. But this is how the Church works.

There are conflicting reports that Pope Francis is offended by the letter, and others which say this is untrue. But such concerns are irrelevant.

The Pope is not an infallible person. The concept of papal infallibility only applies in certain, limited circumstances. Popes can make mistakes and have before. In addition, the clergy can have questions and they are allowed to ask them. The pope may or may not reply, and if the clergy conclude the pope has misworded his statements, they may issue a correction.

This is how all healthy organizations work. No organization can service which does not allow robust discussion between the executive officer and their subordinates. Not even an absolute monarchy is capable of survival if the king does not heed his ministers.

It is premature and inappropriate to criticize either the Pope or the Cardinals when we have only slight information on what is actually happening. Neither party is commenting outside of official statements. In fact, Pope Francs’ remarks to Avvenire may not necessarily be a reply to the Cardinals.

We must allow the fathers of our Church to resolve their questions in the ways that work for them. Our job is to be patient, to follow the teaching of the Church to the best of our faithful ability, and to love one another. It is virtuous to pray for our Holy Father, Pope Francis and the Cardinals who have taken the important step of presenting questions to him.

We trust in the words of Pope Francis. In time, we will understand. It may take fifty years as he suggested. May God’s will, not ours, be done.

By Marshall Connolly


1 comment

  1. Peter Aiello Reply

    Who is right or wrong; the pope or the cardinals? Does it matter if we are now able to bring our personal consciences into the mix?

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories