03 Aug 2016 News No comments

World Youth Day in Panama will be a ‘Latina fiesta’, says bishop

Cardinal Jose Lacunza Maestrojuan said the country would give World Youth Day 2019 a distinctive flavour Panama, which will host World Youth Day in 2019, is a …

Read more

14 Nov 2014 Q&A No comments

Doesn't 1 John 5:11-13 prove "once saved, always saved"?

Full Question The Bible speaks of believers as having eternal life now (1 Jn 5:11-13). This proves "once saved, always saved." Answer Sometimes S…

Read more

04 Oct 2016 News No comments

Two suspects killed Mexican priest after ‘falling out’, prosecutor claims

The chief prosecutor for Michoacan said Fr Jose Alfredo Lopez Guillen was killed after meeting with the men at his residence A Catholic priest abducted in Sept…

Read more

29 Sep 2016 News Comments (1)

India has one of the biggest armies, but doesn't use it -- Why?

Neighboring war torn countries have engaged in three wars since 1947 - but while one attacks relentlessly, the other maintains diplomatic restraint. Pakistan…

Read more

24 Sep 2015 Articles No comments

The World Meeting of Families Catechism

Preparatory Catechesis At each World Meeting of Families (WMOF), the host diocese writes a preparatory catechesis. This is a fundamental part of the meeting, a…

Read more

24 Nov 2014 Articles Comments (7)

Dating tips for Catholics; Dos and Don’ts in relationships

Whether single or in a relationship, dating can be a wonderful, exciting, intimidating, and sometimes bizarre event. The stress of just figuring out what to wea…

Read more

08 Oct 2014 Vatican No comments

As violence ravages homeland, Nigerian bishop hopes in synod

Vatican City, Oct 8, 2014 / 04:46 pm .- Archbishop Ignatius Kaigama of Jos, Nigeria, has high hopes for the outcome of the current bishops’ synod, noting the co…

Read more

20 Oct 2015 News Vatican Comments (1)

Strengthen marriage with truth and mercy, Venezuela's Cardinal Urosa tells synod

Both truth and mercy can be found in consistent Catholic teaching on marriage, Cardinal Jorge Urosa Savino of Caracas told the Synod of Bishops on Thursday. …

Read more

03 Dec 2014 Q&A No comments

Is it a sin to talk for long with women?

Full Question I was perusing an old (1805) Spanish moral theology tome online, the Compendio Moral Salmaticense. As Spanish is not my primary language, reading…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Pornography lessons? Not at my school, says Catholic headmaster

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

Dr James Whitehead has responded to calls for pornography to be taught in schools

The headmaster of Downside School has spoken out against suggestions that pornography should be taught in schools.

Following comments by the broadcaster and journalist Dame Jenni Murray, in which she said teenagers should watch pornography together and analyse it as though it was a Jane Austen novel, Dr James Whitehead said that promoting pornography goes against the ethos of gender equality.

During an appearance at the Cheltenham Literary Festival, Murray suggested schools “put boys and girls together in a class and you show them a pornographic film and you analyse it in exactly the same way as you teach them to read all the other cultures around them".

But in a blogpost for the Independent Schools Council, Dr Whitehead said Jane Austen would be “appalled".

He wrote: “Obviously, the suggestion here is not that pornography should replace texts from the literary canon in English Literature classes, but that a new approach should be taken towards sex education, a position that is being advocated by the House of Commons Women and Equalities Committee. There is a general feeling that young people have lost their way in terms of having an unhealthy approach to sex based on distorted cyber-experience, one which reinforces gender inequality.

“However, young people watching porn in the presence of a teacher is highly problematic in many ways – not least for Safeguarding reasons – and it is a world away from analysing a conversation between Emma and Mr Knightley. Jane Austen, with her quiet endorsement of a Christian understanding of human relationships, would be appalled."

Dr Whitehead went on to say that if we value human dignity, pornography is no service in achieving gender equality. He said: “Many schools in the United Kingdom were founded by Christian organisations; in fact, several thousand remain explicitly Anglican, Catholic or Methodist, and other denominations also run a number of schools. There are also other faith schools run by Jewish, Buddhist or Islamic foundations; many of these would find difficulty in justifying the study of pornography in school. Why? In short, because for the spiritually inclined, it is important that young people focus on the morality that should underpin human relationships, rather than begin to study a form of interaction that is essentially a negation of this.

“Catholic social teaching, for example, places great emphasis on the recognition of gender equality through respect for the individual dignity of every individual person. If we value human dignity as a means of achieving gender equality, this cannot be served through the study of pornography. As the Second Vatican Council put it, “A just society can become a reality only when it is based on the transcendent dignity of the human person". Equality is lost when we forget the dignity of the other; the sacrament of marriage provides for sexual equality within a context of commitment before God. While religions may differ in how they express this, an emphasis on commitment and justice in human relationships is common to most."

The headmaster also cautioned against patronising young people, saying “the vast majority want to live meaningful, positive lives and they do not need to analyse pornography to know that it is essentially demeaning both to watch it and to act it out."

During her talk Jenni Murray, the Woman’s Hour presenter also called for some of the information in SRE to be moved to biology lessons.

She said: “I would put the ‘what goes where’ and how and how babies are made and all of that into biology because that is science. No parent is going to say ‘oh I don’t want my child getting involved in biology or science’, while an awful lot of parents might say, ‘I don’t want my child to have sex education’."



1 comment

  1. Silvano Reply

    There is also an another BIG legal problem. So far, when an adult (a teacher is always an adult) shows pornography to minors, he/she is condemned to years of prison, accused, charged and sentenced as a pedophile. Once we start to allow some adults to do that, without being arrested and put to prison, any one can do it, claiming that he/she was teaching a child some good lessons, by showing a prno movie. Home schooling will be a pedophile activity ground, sexual abusing of children will be allowed, and you name it, it will happen….. wake up society…… wake up. I would arrest that woman that was proposing this legislation, for promoting sexual abuse of children, disguised as school teaching….

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories