30 Apr 2016 Articles Comments (2)

How Do You Know You're Not in the Matrix?

At the heart of the philosophy of Aristotle and St. Thomas Aquinas is the idea that we come into contact with reality through the senses. But what if our senses…

Read more

07 Dec 2015 Americas News No comments

The three slain Priests of Peru

Fr. Miguel Tomaszek and Fr. Zbigniew Strzalkowski both from Poland, and Fr. Alessandro Dordi, from Italy who were slain in Peru by Shining Path rebels in 1991 w…

Read more

19 Jan 2016 News Vatican No comments

Pope Francis met with Royals of Monaco

The Holy Father on monday met with Prince Albert II and Princess Charlene of Monaco. A brief Vatican statement released after the meeting indicated that the …

Read more

07 Nov 2015 Articles Comments (1)

Liturgy of Hours

The Liturgy of the Hours, also known as the Divine Office or the Work of God (Opus Dei), is the daily prayer of the Church, marking the hours of each day and sa…

Read more

26 Mar 2015 Q&A No comments

Did the Church change its teaching about justification to align with Luther's?

Full Question My Protestant friend says that the Catholic Church has finally changed its teaching on justification to line up with Luther's interpretation.…

Read more

08 Jul 2015 Articles Comments (24)

Why does the Catholic Church baptize babies?

Q: Why does the Catholic Church baptize babies? Aren't they too young to understand what is happening to them? A fair question. The easiest and perhaps best…

Read more

24 Feb 2016 Americas News USA Vatican No comments

Priest who defied Vatican to promote Literacy in Nicaragua dies at 82-years of age

In the 1980s Father Fernando Cardenal was among the Nicaraguan Catholic priests that were sanctioned by the Vatican for their involvements with the Daniel Orteg…

Read more

02 Jul 2015 Articles No comments

'The unthinkable is real,' author warns about persecutions of Middle East Christians

Growing unrest in the Middle East is causing great concern for the Christian community around the world, and author George J. Marlin is hoping to enlighten West…

Read more

20 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (6)

If St. Paul says long hair is unnatural for men, why do our portraits of Jesus show him with it?

Full Question In 1 Corinthians 11:14 Paul tells us long hair is degrading to and unnatural for a man. All the pictures of Jesus show him with long hair, so…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Pro-life medics face harassment and discrimination, admits doctors’ union

  • Written by:
  • 1 Reply

Doctors who refuse to take part in abortions are suffering increasingly from harassment and discrimination at work, the British Medical Association has told MPs.

Healthcare professionals are complaining to the union that they are facing pressure to take part in abortions and confronted with glass ceilings to advancement when they refuse, a new report reveals today.

The BMA highlighted the problem in written evidence submitted to a parliamentary inquiry into the working of the conscience clause of the 1967 Abortion Act.

The BMA said in its evidence that it “supports the right of doctors to have a conscientious objection to termination of pregnancy and believes that such doctors should not be marginalised".

“Some doctors have complained of being harassed and discriminated against because of their conscientious objection to abortion," it continues.

“The BMA abhors any instances of harassment or discrimination of doctors on the basis of their views on abortion."

The inquiry by the All Party Parliamentary Pro-Life Group received evidence from hundreds of individuals and institutions, including abortion providers.

In its report, it concluded that the conscience clause was not being upheld and that medical professionals with a moral objection to abortion were vulnerable to victimisation.

Fiona Bruce, the Conservative MP for Congleton, Cheshire, and the chairman of the group, said action must be taken to protect such healthcare professionals.

“This report reveals concerning evidence of doctors and other healthcare professionals being harassed, abused, and denied career choices, as a result of seeking to exercise their legal right to conscientiously object to being involved in the abortion process," she said. “This must stop.

“Our All Party Parliamentary Group calls on Government and all those involved in overseeing healthcare provision to take steps to ensure that the conscience clause is fully respected and observed in practice.

“It is now almost 50 years since Parliament enshrined the conscience clause in law – and in an age when diversity is increasingly celebrated and discrimination deplored it is today more relevant than ever."

The conscience clause states that “no person shall be under any duty, whether by contract or by any statutory or other legal requirement, to participate in any treatment authorised by this Act to which he has a conscientious objection".

But the new report, called “A Report into Freedom of Conscience in Abortion Provision", found that “inadequate observance" of the law and in some cases a total “disregard of the conscience clause".

“This means that, in practice, there is inadequate accommodation for healthcare professionals with a conscientious objection to abortion, contrary to the protection which the 1967 Act is intended to provide," the report says.

“In particular, the treatment of such individuals is far too dependent on the individual attitudes and discretion of their personal line managers or colleagues."

As a result pressure was increasing on pro-life doctors to refer women who want abortions to colleagues willing to authorise them, which meant they were still culpable.

Promotion is denied to doctors with conscientious objections while access to specialities like obstetrics and gynaecology have been made practically impossible for medical students with objections, the inquiry found.

The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists refused to give evidence to the inquiry and was severely criticised in the report for operating a policy which explicitly discriminates against the advancement of students with such objections.

But Ann Furedi, the chief executive of the British Pregnancy Advisory Service, the largest private chain of abortion clinics in the UK, said that even her organisation allowed some doctors to object.

“At BPAS, some doctors feel unable to carry out, or be trained to carry out abortions beyond a particular gestation," she said in a written submission. “Their view is respected and they are able to treat those clients that they feel they can treat."

Dr Arianne Shahvisi, lecturer in medical ethics and humanities for the medical school at the University of Sussex, said in her oral submission, however, that students should not go into medicine if they were not willing to participate in abortions.

“If a person finds abortion objectionable, they should not pursue employment in which their only options are to be at one or two removes from abortion provision," she said.

“In disclosing a moral reservation, doctors risk producing moral distress in the patient or even of deterring the patient from proceeding with the abortion," she added.

“The disclosure of a moral reservation by a powerful and respected person to a vulnerable person, against the backdrop of a society in which abortion is still stigmatised, seems deeply problematic."

The report said Dr Shahvisi’s position excluded “those with a conscientious objection to abortion from training in such fields as General Practice, Obstetrics and Gynaecology, nursing, and midwifery".

“Should assisted dying ever be legalised in the UK, a whole host of other medical fields would also be excluded for the pro-life individual," the report said.

The report recommended a review of training to ensure that the conscience clause is properly understood and respected and called for an end to any requirements of an objecting doctor to refer abortions elsewhere.

It recommended the establishment of an appeals system to help people who feel victimised because of their objection and the protections offered by the conscience clause to be extended to cover wider numbers of healthcare professionals.

It also called for the 2010 Equality Act to be amended to incorporate the principle of “reasonable accommodation" to encourage employers to avoid flashpoints with employees in the first place.

In her submission, Dr Mary Neal, senior lecturer in law at the University of Strathclyde, said: “We should not expect someone who believes abortion to be seriously morally wrong to be willing to participate in it in any capacity, and conscience provisions should be drafted and interpreted so as to protect health care practitioners against any such expectations."



1 comment

  1. Patrick Gannon Reply

    And if a Muslim wants a job in a butcher shop, but refuses to serve pork to clients, we should respect his wishes? The shop owner should hire a person who will not complete the job description?

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories