Follow usTwitterFacebook

Latest

22 Oct 2015 Europe News No comments

Fears grow among Christians in Nepal

Concern about security is growing following the bombing of three churches Fears are growing among Christians in Nepal about their future security, according …

Read more

04 Nov 2016 News No comments

Venezuela opposition scrap protest march in response to Vatican diplomacy

The opposition alliance also tentatively welcomed the release of four jailed activists and agreed to delay a symbolic trial of President Maduro Venezuela’s opp…

Read more

13 Nov 2015 News USA No comments

Bishop Edward Burns: Victims of abuse have helped us see the errors of the past

According to the head of the US Bishops' Committee on Child and Youth Protection Bishop Edward Burns, "Victims of abuse have helped us see the errors of the pas…

Read more

11 Sep 2014 Vatican No comments

Pope Francis to Address European Parliament in Strasbourg

In a statement, Vatican spokesman Father Federico Lombardi confirmed that a communiqué issued this morning by the European Parliament was correct, and that Pope…

Read more

18 Apr 2016 United Kingdom No comments

English and Welsh bishops fix a date for their National Eucharistic Congress

England and Wales fixed a date for its first National Eucharistic Congress in more than a dozen years. This week, at the bishops’ conference’s spring meeting…

Read more

14 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

Keep faith-based hiring discrimination, religious leaders tell Obama

Seventy supporters of religion-based hiring discrimination urged President Obama Thursday to continue to permit government-funded faith groups to employ people …

Read more

16 Oct 2015 Middle East News No comments

As violence takes over Jerusalem again, a bishop says: we need the Lord’s help

Bishop Shomali says it is painful to see violence return to Jerusalem Auxiliary Bishop William Shomali, Latin Patriarchate chancellor, has said it is painful…

Read more

22 Aug 2016 News No comments

Pro-life campaigners welcome suspension of Marie Stopes services

Inspections at abortion clinics in England have prompted serious concerns about patient welfare Pro-life campaigners have welcomed the suspension of some servi…

Read more

09 Mar 2016 Europe Middle East News No comments

Catholic Aid leader alarms emergence of a new state of emergency due to refugee crisis at Greece-Macedonia border

With a rising number of refugees and migrants, traveling across the Mediterranean Sea to seek safe asylum in Greece, the migrant crisis in Greece is entering a …

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
«
»

Should we applaud after the closing hymn?

Full Question

One of my friends suggests that we should not applaud the choir after the closing hymn. He says that the song should direct souls to the Lord. I find it unnatural if we don’t applaud.

Answer

The church is not a concert hall and the liturgy is not a performance. We are there to direct our attention to God—not to each other. There is a time and place for everything. The church is for prayer—not performances. If you want to convey your appreciation for the music, compliment the director after Mass.










28 comments

  1. Greg Madera Reply

    i beg to disagree, when we sing to the Lord, WE ARE PERFORMING TO THE LORD. if the choir sang greatly to the Lord, I would applaud not for whatever reason, but an appreciation of a group of people who exerted great effort to praise God in a very inspiring ways. Remember, St. Augustine, he who sings well, prays twice. people should be glad that some people have praise God with extra effort, and that should inspire people to sing well during masses and other sacred celebration. after all, WHO ARE WE to judge whether our actions or singing at that is pleasing to GOD. only GOD knows.

    1. John Ward Reply

      Our Priest lovingly provided this same guidance recently. I am a member of one of our choirs. We are part of the liturgical actions to the lifting of minds and hearts to God. The Holy Mass is our call to celebrate the summit and source of our faith . When we as a choir use our gifts in humility we serve and offer it to God with the Church . Our voices with the Church an offering of love. Applause detaches us from what was given with others in celebration of Thanks Giving. John

  2. Julius Reply

    I don’t see anything wrong with clapping as long as we clap for The Lord God.

  3. Antipolo Delilah R. Reply

    I think it is ok to applaud the choir after the mass. It’s just one way of thanking them for their beautiful service to the Lord.

  4. Catherine Lembke Reply

    I Like to kneel and pray after mass and I find it very disruptive to have people clapping which usually leads to loud conversations in church. Whatever happened to that beautiful calming quiet after the music is over and you can reflect on the Mass and your day ahead? Sorry, but I don’t think it is the time for concert atmosphere.

  5. Charles Spevak Reply

    I am a former Catholic, now a evangelical Christian. We applaud and raise our hands for the glory of our redemption after worship songs, in grateful appreciation for Jesus’s redeeming work on the cross that took our sin debt away. All Glory to HIS Holy Name!!!

  6. Mai Reply

    i don’t see anything wrong, too.

  7. mary Teresa otuka Reply

    Sometimes I think we are ignorant of where we are try thanking the choir and you will see their appreciation after all you must have participated in the singing do clap for your self

  8. Andrew Reply

    I agree it is fine to applaud after Mass. It is a sign of our affirmation to God. Some of the answers given seem to come from the “dark ages”

  9. Ivy Reply

    Giving applause to the Lord simply tells Lord you are Great!! We do the applause every closing and it gives a good feeling knowing you attend the mass because of our Lord. Our Lord is a performer of great things to our lives and applause is just one good way of showing our happiness..I understand the conservatism of many priest but usually the celebrant of the mass in the closing will tell the
    Parishioners to give a big applause to the Lord!

  10. Eric Reply

    Guess I’m different then..knowing the mass is a holy celebration…key word…the music ministry uses the gifts given them and that music calls out the holy spirit in them and you. An applaud of thanks at the end after the final blessing to go forth is well in order!

  11. christel Reply

    I think that we should always applaud the Lord, always give a big big clap to the God Almighty.

  12. Cheryl Myers Cotter Reply

    If you want to applaud go to a concert, not a Church. If you want to socialize, go outside. Some people actually might (gasp) want to PRAY before they leave the building. If you are so moved by a some by all means, stop and thank the organist or choir director, but be prepared – they might faint from shock.

  13. Paul Schultz (@PWSchultz) Reply

    Here are a couple of quotes to chew over: “It is not fitting to applaud the servant in the house of his Master.” (Pope Pius X); “Whenever applause breaks out in the liturgy because of some human achievement, it is a sure sign that the essence of liturgy has totally disappeared and been replaced by a kind of religious entertainment” (Pope Benedict XVI)

  14. Ellen S. Reply

    Applause is a joyful noise, so why not? God approves of gratitude. I sing in the choir and while it’s not necessary to hear applause, it’s appreciated after special programs like Christmas and Easter.

  15. Helen Jauregui Reply

    As a music director, choir director and organist…..it depends on the culture. Generally, in our parish (predominantly white, city/suburban) people tend not to applaud after the closing hymn as they are GONE. When the choir does an anthem after communion, a few people will begin applause and it spreads, but it feels VERY uncomfortable to us (even though the choir members feel flattered, of course). The point of the song is to lead people into prayer, and it really drives me crazy when people clap during what should be a moment of awe. I know they mean well, to be appreciative, but I would be happier if they just let the music hang in the air in silence.

  16. Marilyn Reply

    As a cantor I think it’s odd to have applause at the end of every mass, in most masses the choir isn’t present. I can understand if the Halleluia Chorus or such ends a mass, but this happens at my parish after every mass where there is music. Not sure when this started, but it was not always the case.

  17. neleh Reply

    Praising the Lord, and showing appreciation to the choir in the form of clapping is perfectly appropriate.
    Who said giving praise should be stiff and unnatural. If one goes to church and is not allowed to feel free to move ones body to what is felt during praise, then one is spiritually dead.

  18. Andrew Reply

    In a Catholic Church, applause is not appropriate! I say this as an organist and director, when we play/sing at Mass, we are not performers. We are worshippers just as the congregation, priest, and other ministers of the Mass. We are simply and humbly doing our job. You wouldn’t applaud the priest or deacon at the end of every homily, you wouldn’t applaud the altar server because they carried that cross oh-so-proudly, or the lector because they pronounced those words so clearly. We are all doing our part and applauding actually diminishes what we do. A simple thank you will do.

  19. Rick Duffy Reply

    As a choir member, I’m always appreciative of those who applaud for our ministry. More often than not, our priest will ask the congregation to acknowledge the choir, but it does happen spontaneously too! I usually joke that the parishioners are delighted we’ve stopped singing! 🙂 HA!

  20. Estrella Boquiren-Masi Reply

    Choir is a Ministry. They sing to the lord which uplift your heart. I don’t see anything wrong in clapping after th final sing. It’s like saying “thank you Lord.”

  21. Thomas Loy Bumgarner Reply

    Sorry, I am Lutheran and am totally against applauding after worship. Catholics, Episcopalians/Anglicans, and Lutherans are not Pentecostal

  22. kuchat Reply

    Why applaud? Do u applaud in an occult meeting or a native juju mans house? The church is a house of prayer and God is always in a quiet silent place. Not riotous concert halls and market places. Soon, you will like comedians to come and perform in church to add a colourful ceremony to it all.

  23. Tom Flynn Reply

    If we consider the choir a ministry then applauding is not appropriate. Would we applaud the priest after the consecration? Surely we should be far more grateful for the Real Presence of Christ than for any music. Why not applaud a good reader, a good alter server, a good Eucharistic minister? The only reason there is applause is because we are used to do that after a performance – not what the mass is about

  24. Rose Ramirez Reply

    Applause after depend of what occasion is. But applause shoudent go for the choir but applause should be to praise God. Honestly, I find it very annoying listening to a soft and out of tune performance of choir. It make me more sleepy than giving me more excitement to celebrate. The holy mass. Sorry for this but it’s true. I saw a lot of mass goers doing the same thing.

  25. Michael Thomas Reply

    The mass is not a performance… all too often I’ve visited churches where the musical performances seem more to showcase talent than to offer praise. We come not to be entertained but to receive spiritual nourishment. Nothing should distract from that purpose. Front and center at every mass is Jesus and he’s not there to share the spotlight. We have 6 days and 23 hours each week for which we can pursue narcissistic interests and American Idol fantasies… can we not offer up just one solemn hour to focus on the Savior of the World and be bathed in His Divine Mercy?

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories