29 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

Philadelphia mayor says media scared people from seeing pope

News reports about extensive security in place for Pope Francis’ visit may have deterred people from attending, the mayor said Monday, while calling the weekend…

Read more

13 Aug 2016 Middle East News USA Vatican Comments (1)

New Iraqi priests bring 'power, hope, and courage'

Fr. Roni Salim Momika, one of three priests ordained in an Erbil refugee camp Friday, said the event has turned the dreary mood of displaced Christians into one…

Read more

20 Apr 2016 Articles Comments (2)

“Bathroom Bill" Is Not Hateful Bigotry

By now you’ve probably heard about celebrities and companies standing up to discrimination and human rights abuses taking place all over the world. Rock s…

Read more

29 Mar 2015 Q&A No comments

In the Apostle's Creed it says Jesus rose twice. How is this possible?

Full Question In the Apostle's Creed it says Jesus rose twice. How is this possible? Answer Jesus rose from the dead only once. The Apostle’s Creed…

Read more

27 Sep 2016 Articles Comments (2)

Learning Holy Courage and Living Faith from the Book of Job

Job did not follow God just because He was so good to him, but because He is God. So should we. When we encounter the inevitability of loss, suffering, difficul…

Read more

17 Aug 2016 Americas Europe News USA Vatican No comments

Compassion is not just an attitude but a call to action, says Pope

Jesus’ compassion toward people in need is not a vague sentiment, but a calling for Christians to bring that same compassion to others, Pope Francis has said. …

Read more

31 Oct 2014 Articles Comments (10)

Stumpers for the Jehovah's Witnesses

The sect known as Jehovah’s Witnesses (JWs) began with Charles Taze Russell in the 1870’s. Russell was raised a Presbyterian, then joined the Congregational chu…

Read more

27 Jan 2016 Europe News No comments

Court's Ruling on Abortion

A state pro-life group expressed its disapproval after The United States Supreme Court refused to hear a case on Monday, that overturned North Dakota’s limits o…

Read more

30 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

Picture gallery: Memorable moments of Pope Francis in America

A picture gallery celebrating Pope Francis's visit to the US A picture gallery celebrating Pope Francis's visit to the US …

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

The Bible says that Peter wasn’t in Rome. So how could he be its first bishop?

Full Question

Catholics claim Peter as the first pope because he served as Bishop of Rome. But the Bible says he was never there. Paul, writing from Rome, says, “Only Luke is with me” (2 Tim. 4:11). This by itself proves Peter wasn’t there.


Actually, the most it could prove is that Peter wasn’t there when Paul was writing. It doesn’t prove that Peter never was there. Maybe he was just out of town.

Don’t read more than is warranted into a verse. If you follow your line of reasoning, you’ll have to say no other Christians at all were in Rome, other than Paul and Luke, but we know that Rome had a large Christian community–they weren’t all out of town on the same day, were they?

In fact, the Bible does allude to Peter’s being in Rome. Peter concludes his first epistle with a cryptic greeting from “Babylon.” This was the early Church’s code word for Rome. The term didn’t mean the city of Babylon which figures so greatly in the Old Testament, though the code word was chosen precisely because of what ancient Babylon had done to the Jews–the Romans were doing likewise to Christians.

Why did the early Christians, in their letters, write “I’m in Babylon” instead of “I’m in Rome”? Because the authorities were hunting for them–the Church was being persecuted–and mail delivery was unreliable.

You never knew when a Roman official would confiscate one of your letters. So, if you didn’t want to advertise your whereabouts to the disloyal opposition, you used code words.

The scriptural evidence may not convince you of Peter’s presence in Rome. Fair enough. But you ought to look also at other early writings and at the archaeological evidence. (You owe it to yourself and to Catholics to examine all the available evidence.)

Irenaeus, in Against Heresies (A.D. 190), said Matthew wrote his Gospel “while Peter and Paul were evangelizing in Rome.” Dionysius of Corinith, about A.D. 170, referred to “the planting that was made by Peter and Paul at Rome.”

What about the archaeological evidence? In the middle decades of this century scientists conducted digs under St. Peter’s Basilica to verify or disprove the tradition that the church had been constructed over Peter’s tomb.

And what do you think they found? That’s right: the tomb. Pope Paul VI was able to announce that conclusive proof had been discovered–for instance, neighboring crypts on which were written grafitti such as, “Buried near Peter.” For a popular account of the excavations, read John Evangelist Walsh’s The Bones of St. Peter.



  1. Laura-Katharine Christopher Reply

    I always assumed that Jesus placed his ministry in the person of Peter rather than a place or a building. Peter was the “church” cornerstone. The actual church building didn’t come until later.

  2. Parvaiz Nazir Reply

    St,Peter was in Rome when He Crucified on cross

  3. Ignacio de Antioquía (@73libros) Reply

    Actually, the Bible makes clear Peter was in Rome. 1 Peter ends with a greeting of Peter and his community from “Babylon" (1 Pt 5:13), a code name for Rome in the early church; name also used in Apocalypse or Book of Revelations.

  4. Carlos Reply

    I’m not even sure why this is even a question. Saint Peter was crucified at the Vatican Hill – something that was documented by both Christians and Romans alike. And this is even before we acknowledge the belief that Saint Peter’s Basilica is built directly above Saint Peter’s Tomb (which I personally believe it is).

  5. Mitchell Thurner Reply

    “Don’t read more than is warranted into a verse” I agree. That’s exactly why I am no longer Catholic. I do agree that Peter was in Rome, however. I also agree that he was the first bishop

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories