Latest

25 Oct 2016 News Comments (1)

3600 Christians and Jews slaughtered - Evidence of an invasion discovered in Jerusalem

When money was stolen from Jewish temples and over 3,600 citizens in Jerusalem were killed, the First Jewish Revolt began. Gessius Florus, a Roman procurator…

Read more

15 Oct 2015 News USA Comments (1)

Vatican opens homeless shelter near St Peter’s Square

Housed in a Jesuit-owned building, the Gift of Mercy shelter was created by funds from the papal almoner The Vatican opened the Gift of Mercy, a shelter for …

Read more

09 Mar 2016 Europe Middle East News No comments

Catholic Aid leader alarms emergence of a new state of emergency due to refugee crisis at Greece-Macedonia border

With a rising number of refugees and migrants, traveling across the Mediterranean Sea to seek safe asylum in Greece, the migrant crisis in Greece is entering a …

Read more

03 Feb 2016 Q&A Comments (1)

Does "the Black Pope" wield the true power in the Vatican?

Full Question I heard that the Vatican is run by an individual called "the black pope," who holds all the real power. What do you say to th…

Read more

26 Dec 2014 Q&A Comments (13)

How do I explain that the Catholic Church did not split from the Christian church?

Full Question Someone I know claims that the Catholic Church divided from the "Christian church" around A.D. 900. I know he is incorrect, but how do I expl…

Read more

07 Jun 2016 News No comments

Religious rivalries put to one side as work begins to renovate Christ’s tomb

A team of experts began a historic restoration project in Jerusalem's Church of the Holy Sepulchre on Monday A team of experts began a historic renovation on M…

Read more

20 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (15)

Did God create hell?

Full Question If God created everything, then didn't he create hell, too? If he created hell, then is hell good, since everything God created was good? …

Read more

29 Jul 2016 Americas Asia-Pacific Europe News USA Vatican Comments (1)

Heroism and sacrifice: The Catholic history of Auschwitz

Pope Francis sat quietly in one of Auschwitz's most ominous prison cells, praying in what had been the inhumane living space of St. Maximilian Kolbe, a Catholic…

Read more

23 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

‘This generation must tackle climate change,’ says Pope Francis at the White House

President Obama welcomed Pope Francis to America during a ceremony at the White House Pope Francis has urged action climate change during a welcoming ceremon…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
«
»

Was this priest wrong to refuse to baptize a seriously ill newborn?


Full Question

The chaplain of our local government hospital refused to baptize a sick newborn. The doctors told the family to get the priest because the infant was in critical condition. When the priest arrived and found out that the parents were temporarily absent, he refused to administer emergency baptism and confirmation. A few hours later, when the baby was about to die, the doctor administered emergency baptism. I am a doctor who has done at least one emergency baptism and taught other medical students to do the same; I find the actions of the priest hard to understand. Did the priest have sufficient grounds to refuse administering emergency baptism to a dying infant whose parents were not around?

Answer

The priest in question violated canon law, and possibly the moral law, in refusing to baptize the baby. He needs to be informed of what the Church teaches. In cases of urgent necessity and specifically with cases of children under the age of seven, canon law requires that they be baptized without delay (CIC 867 §2). When there is danger of the baby dying, there is no requirement that the parents be present, that they be practicing Catholics, or even married in the Church. Thank God for that doctor and other doctors like yourself.

 










17 comments

  1. Noel David Reply

    The priest was absolutely wrong. Many a child and adult have been deprived of receiving the Lord’s message and the sacraments due to the heartlessness and rigid stands taken by the priests/nuns/Laity (Church)…. The Lord does not delay in healing, forgiving and saving people from their misery/pain….. Jesus Christ Our Lord is ever willing to forgive and save sinners… He forgives any sinner who comes to HIM that very moment…. The thief who was crucified along with HIM is promised Paradise that very day … and he is not made to go through all the rigmarole to obtain forgiveness for ages as our bishops/priests/nuns and faithful in every parish/place…. We (Clergy and Laity) with all our ruthless, inhumane, selfish, rigid and unjust ways – are only making a mockery of the Lord’s immense love for humankind and HIS saving grace….

  2. Gabriel Reply

    The priest was most grieviously wrong in this situation. It just goes to show that the people of God must pray for his conversion fully to the faith he professes to believe. We, layity, are not held blameless before God in this. We do have direct guidance to pray always, and to pray constantly for those whom are ordained.

  3. Lyndia Fogarty Reply

    I agree with what wss said .I think that there need to be more softer way Jesus Christ was a gentle person who help and forgave all

  4. keda smith Reply

    I sometimes wonder about the education of these men when they are in the seminary. How could a ordained priest refuse to baptise anyone in an emergency situation especially little children.

  5. Mike Reply

    Is this just a bogus story? There is no indication why the priest did not baptize and confirm the baby besides the article indicating that the parents were “temporarily absent.” This article is very vague and appears to just be pondering a scenario rather than informing others of an incident. If this did occur, to be fair the priest has to give a reason why he did not baptize and confirm the baby.

  6. sarah cutter Reply

    Ifind it difficult 2 belive this story why was this priest not reported not reported 2 his bishop did they even bother 2 ask his name the name of his church or if he was even a priest at all any lay person who is catholic can baptize a child who is in danger of dying hence the doctor it all sounds far fetched 2 me.

  7. john Reply

    priest was not wrong becasue of absence of parents,, you need direct permission from parents to baptise. Otherwise just like the case in Baton Rouge (regarding confidentiality of confession) parents can sue the priest and diocese for baptising their child without direct premission and presence of parents.

    1. Jacob Reply

      Amen for that…..I totally agree ….& thanks for someone understand the whole teaching of the HOLY CHURCH……hope other can see this matter in different points of view

    2. Joshua Reply

      Actually you don’t need any such permission. In danger of death, infants are to be baptized even against the will of the parents. And fear of a lawsuit is not grounds not to be damned when judged for the mortal sin of omission that this can be.

      In Postremo mense Benedict XIV settled questions of morality and law here, rejecting to opinion of some (Duns Scotus e.g.) that babies could laudably be taken from unbelievers and baptized, and affirming St. Thomas’s view that they ought not to be. But in danger of death, any infant ought to be.

      Current Canon Law reiterates this:

      Can. 867 §1.

      §2. An infant in danger of death is to be baptized without delay.

      Can. 868 §1. For an infant to be baptized licitly:

      §2. An infant of Catholic parents or even of non-Catholic parents is baptized licitly in danger of death even against the will of the parents.

  8. Victor Reply

    Cooked up story. how can a well trained catholic priest do that and walk out unquestioned by his authority or even his own conscience?

  9. marmay Reply

    Yeah, this truly sounds bogus–probably just to prompt clergy-haters, like some in this chain, to fire away!!! A priest refusing to perform something as BASIC a teaching????? Please…

  10. Nidal Reply

    How can parents leave a dying new born baby, if this story is true the priest should be heard before making any judgement.

  11. Yvonne Luna Reply

    That’s what sticks out in my mind…where were the parents? And if this did occur why did no one question the reason behind the priests refusal. I can’t clearly see this happening with a trained priest…this would be very cold, showing no compassion for the baby or its little soul.

  12. china Reply

    SUPPOSE THE DOCTORS DIDNT ADMINISTER BAPTISM AND THE BABY HAPPENED TO DIE WHAT WOULD BE THE EFFECT TO THE BABY?

  13. Susana Rosende Reply

    Twenty-seven years ago, I had to beg a priest to baptize my dying newborn, and he was especially hesitant because my ex-husband was not a practicing Catholic. In fact, he was Jewish. The priest finally agreed when I promised to raise our son, Sean, in the Catholic faith if he survived. He didn’t tell us when he would perform the ceremony, so we weren’t present in the ICN when he did, and the Baptism Certificate didn’t designate the Catholic Faith, but said instead NON-DENOMINATIONAL. Our son didn’t make it, and I was hurt by what I thought was an extremely uncompassionate priest and in response, I strayed from my Catholic faith for years.

  14. Susana Rosende Reply

    I believe this occurred because a similar situation happened to my family. Twenty-seven years ago, I had to beg a priest to baptize my dying newborn, and he was especially hesitant because my ex-husband was not a practicing Catholic. In fact, he was Jewish. The priest finally agreed when I promised to raise our son, Sean, in the Catholic faith if he survived. He didn’t tell us when he would perform the ceremony, so we weren’t present in the ICN when he did, and the Baptism Certificate didn’t designate the Catholic Faith, but said instead NON-DENOMINATIONAL. Our son didn’t make it, and I was hurt by what I thought was an extremely uncompassionate priest, and in response, I strayed from my Catholic faith for years.

  15. Okwe Reply

    Why would the parents of a child in such critical condition be far away from the child.?

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories