Follow usTwitterFacebook

Latest

26 Apr 2016 Middle East - Africa No comments

South African bishop warns politicians against war rhetoric

Bishop Gabuza has criticised comments made by the leader of the Economic Freedom Fighters War rhetoric from South African political leaders could incite electi…

Read more

21 Sep 2015 Americas News No comments

Serve others, not ideologies, Pope urges Cubans at Mass in Havana

'We do not serve ideas, we serve people,' Francis tells hundreds of thousands in Revolution Square Pope Francis has told the Cuban people that love and servi…

Read more

15 Oct 2015 News Vatican No comments

Do not be fooled by ‘doctors of law’ who limit God’s love, says Pope Francis

Pope says God's love is not reserved to those who follow the Commandments Obedience to God’s commandments must be the response to his limitless love, but it …

Read more

30 Oct 2014 Articles Comments (23)

Jehovah’s Witnesses and the Cross

Jehovah’s Witnesses believe that the Greek word translated as “cross” in the New Testament, stauros, actually means “upright stake” or, in their words, “torture…

Read more

19 Feb 2015 Articles No comments

Ash Wednesday makes me think twice about something: the common practice among Catholics of each person’s selecting his own private sacrifice to observe during t…

Read more

11 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (6)

Can angels be male or female?

Full Question Could you please answer the question for me whether angels can be he or she? I thought they were neither. Answer You are correc…

Read more

19 Sep 2015 News Vatican No comments

No one can play dumb on what's happening in the Middle East, Pope says

While the international community can't seem to find solutions to the current crisis ravaging the Middle East, thanks to the media it's caught the world's atten…

Read more

02 Sep 2015 Middle East - Africa News No comments

Why women are needed to help end violence in Africa

Women are the key to reconciliation in both the family and society. This was the message given to women from nearly twenty countries across Africa who conven…

Read more

18 Aug 2016 Exhortations No comments

We Are ALL Called to Labor in the Vineyard of the Lord

Do we see the Church as Some-One, the Risen Christ truly present in His mystical Body, into whom we have been Baptized and now live? Do we, like those early bel…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
«
»

Why all the fuss about The Da Vinci code, considering it’s just a piece of fiction?

Full Question

I have just read Catholic Answers’ report on the novel The Da Vinci Code by Dan Brown. I have to say that the Church seems very flustered about the book. Surely the Church has nothing to fear from a work of fiction, no matter what the view of the author.

Answer

Actually, the Church as an institution has had no comment, one way or the other, on The Da Vinci Code. The book has not been placed by the Vatican on any “forbidden books” list nor have any “official” sanctions been placed on it. Those who are concerned are faithful Catholics, clerical and lay, who have seen the book confuse Catholics and other Christians about the character of people in the early Church, the relationship of Jesus Christ and Mary Magdalene, and orthodox Christian doctrine.

Although many have claimed that Christians shouldn’t be concerned about the novel because it is fiction, Brown himself has touted the book as the fruit of factual research. He opens the novel with a “Fact Page” that purports to be unvarnished truth. In other words, he wants people to believe that his conclusions in the novel are true.

Even had Brown not advertised his book to reveal hidden “truths” about Christianity, the device of fiction does not grant authors the right to disseminate historical untruths. Analogously, a novel that purported to reveal that the Holocaust never happened and that Adolf Hitler was really a great guy would be (quite properly) discounted by people of good will everywhere as anti-Semitic agitprop. Indeed, in this day and age, such a book would likely never see publication, at least by mainstream publishers. If such a book as that could not be defended with the disclaimer “It’s only a novel!” then other books that spread historical untruths also cannot be defended as “only fiction.”









wpsd_autopost:
1

1 comment

  1. Patrick Gannon Reply

    What nonsense. There’s no way for the Church to prove what is or is not a historical truth because no historical evidence exists – only evidence of a religious or mythical background. Even for the religious (which of course is biased) evidence that we have – none of it is original. All we have is copies, and the copies we have contain many errors, contradictions, edits, etc. and date to 100 years or more after Jesus’ death, and most copy remnants are much older than that. Jesus, if he existed was a virtual unknown, as no historians of the time wrote about him. The first historian to write about him (and much is disputed about what he actually wrote) didn’t write until the mid-90’s CE, more than six decades after the events in question. To accuse Brown of playing fast and loose with historical evidence is ridiculous because no such historical evidence from the time of Jesus exists, and there were a number of historians at the time writing about other people who did in fact exist. If Jesus existed, he was apparently a virtual unknown to all of them.
    .
    It’s unlikely that Jesus was a physical person. Paul writes of a cosmic Jesus who he probably though was crucified in outer space by Satan (that’s where they thought Hell was then). He doesn’t know anything about Jesus’ family, birth, ministry, disciples, miracles or facts about his crucifixion or resurrection – none of it. Wouldn’t you expect him to answer questions from his congregations with examples from Jesus’ life and death? Wouldn’t you expect his sheeple to have questions about Jesus’ life? There’s nothing. It seems they understood Jesus to be a cosmic god, like others of the time. Paul doesn’t know anything about a real, physical Jesus. It was whoever the author of Mark got his info from that apparently made Jesus a flesh and blood human, copying from several mythologies active at that time like Romulus and the Ascension of Isaiah.
    .
    It’s possible that there was a real physical Jesus, but the odds are lopsidedly against it. For a very detailed investigation of all the evidence available to us, see Richard Carrier’s study on the historicity of Jesus. I always figured there was a real Jesus even if he wasn’t a god, but having read his book, I now doubt it.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories