25 Jun 2016 Articles Comments (1)

Should Christians Fly the Rainbow Flag?

In the wake of the recent Orlando nightclub attack, many people, including Christians, have superimposed a rainbow flag over their social media profile pictures…

Read more

09 Sep 2015 Articles Comments (6)

The Origin of Sign of the Cross?

The sign of the cross is a beautiful gesture which reminds the faithful of both the cross of salvation while invoking the Holy Trinity. Technically, the sign o…

Read more

24 Jul 2015 Articles No comments

Why this Catholic health care development is a game-changer for women

With the hope of providing authentic and ethical health care for women, Dr. Thomas Hilgers, creator of Natural Procreative Technology, has worked for decades to…

Read more

26 Apr 2016 Articles No comments

Crown of Thorns

Crown of Thorns.—Although Our Savior's Crown of Thorns is mentioned by three Evangelists and is often alluded to by the early Christian Fathers, such as Clement…

Read more

04 Oct 2016 News USA Vatican No comments

Pope Francis urges US Catholics to pray before voting

Pope Francis spoke to reporters on the Papal Plane from Georgia and Azerbaijan on Sunday, where he revealed the best way US Catholics can approach the upcoming …

Read more

19 Aug 2016 Articles No comments

How we stopped a Black Mass at Harvard

A shot putter who won a silver medal in Rio is a member of the Knights of Columbus who counts priests and religious among his friends and role models. Joe Ko…

Read more

17 Sep 2014 Vatican No comments

Sixth Meeting of Council of Cardinals Wraps Up

The director of the Holy See Press Office, Father Federico Lombardi, provided an update on the sixth meeting of the Council of Cardinals, which began on Monday,…

Read more

17 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (7)

Why shouldn't we applaud the choir at the end of Mass?

Full Question One of my friends suggests that we should not applaud the choir after the closing hymn. He says that the song should direct souls t…

Read more

03 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (5)

What is the Catholic view of women?

Full Question I am a Muslim woman considering becoming a Christian. Can you tell me what is the Catholic view about women? In Islam "they" say that women a…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Why call the Watch Tower Society a false religion for changing doctrines?

Full Question
Catholics claim that the Jehovah’s Witnesses are following a false religion because of changes the Watch Tower Society has made in its doctrines. Such refinements are nothing more than the Society moving closer to a proper understanding of Bible prophecies, as Proverbs 4:18 states. Besides, the Catholic Church itself has changed doctrines, but you would not label it a false religion, would you?
We need a closer look at the verses preceding Proverbs 4:18, which reads as follows in the Jehovah’s Witnesses’ New World Translation: “But the path of the righteous ones is like the bright light that is getting lighter and lighter until the day is firmly established.”

An examination of the context shows that the passage is contrasting righteous people with wicked people. The “path” in this context refers to their respective lifestyles, not to the development of doctrine, as the Watch Tower Society (WTS) would have us believe.

The “bright light” represents the righteous person becoming increasingly obedient to God’s commands and living a virtuous life. There is no warrant whatsoever for claiming this passage deals with an increased understanding of Bible prophecies.

What the WTS calls “refinements” or “adjustments” are in actuality instances of it having made false predictions or having taught false interpretations of Bible passages. When these blunders come to light (no pun intended), the WTS scrambles to disguise them, alleging that its understanding was not fully developed and thus needed an “increase of light.” In other words, when the WTS changes a doctrine (by reversal, flip-flop, or outright elimination) or when it wants to slough off a false prophecy, it asserts that “new light” has been received and has enabled it to better “understand” a teaching or prophecy.

The former teaching (“old light”) is then discarded, and the “new light,” which is called a “refinement,” supposedly brings the WTS to a fuller understanding of the prophecy or teaching in question. But truth neither changes nor contradicts itself. If a former teaching were true in the first place, there would have been no need for any changes. Truth does not grow “truer,” and its essence does not change to something else. In the case of the WTS, we do see current teachings contradicting earlier teachings and doctrines going back and forth between opposite interpretations. This is not maturation but mutation.

The Catholic Church has never changed any defined doctrine. Disciplinary matters, such as priestly celibacy or abstaining from meat on Fridays in Lent, can and do change, but these items are not doctrines and do not come from the deposit of faith left by the apostles. Consequently, the Church may change or dispense such matters as it sees fit.

Also, while you may see certain differences and even changes within or between the teachings of individual theologians, but when the Church defines something as dogma, it doesn’t change.

For developments in Catholic teaching to be grounds for accusations of false religion, these would have to involve reversals of defined doctrine. But this simply has never happened in the Church’s entire history.



  1. Luis Reply

    Yes the Catholic Church has never reversed course on defined doctrine, I mean except for Hellfire, that doesn’t count does it? I also guess the years that the Church was behind the genocide during the Spanish inquisition not to mention the role in the genocide in Rwanda doesn’t count either? No that one doesnt because the church is still behind military action even though the bible clearly tells us to lay down our weapons and be peaceable people. So the Catholic church has not changed doctrine on genocide. Ill stick with the JW’s thanks.

  2. sol Reply

    a doctrine is something taught… in my lifetime i have seen limbo disappear, hell be a distancing from god, meat on friday ok… in the past, priests were allowed to marry.. 1 timothy 4:1-3.. ps: i would have chosen the jw’s in ww2 germany over priests any day, as most of the priests were in cahoots with hitler.. it was called a concordat.. how many jw’s fought in hitlers army?

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories