Follow usTwitterFacebook

Latest

An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

10 Nov 2015 News Vatican No comments

Pope Francis outlines the importance of Rest for Workers

On Saturday, November 7, at St. Peter’s Square with employees of the Italian National Social Security Institute, Pope Francis acknowledged the organization’s co…

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

26 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (3)

How could a perfect God create man who is by nature sinful?

Full Question How could a perfect God create man who is by nature sinful? I know we all have free will, but why would not God create beings that are for th…

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

29 Aug 2016 Uncategorized Comments (2)

Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg meets Pope Francis

Pair discuss 'how to use communication technologies to alleviate poverty' Facebook founder Mark Zuckerberg and his wife, Priscilla Chan, have met Pope Fran…

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

11 Dec 2014 Q&A No comments

Religion is irrational, right?

Full Question There's no way you're going to get me to buy Christianity. I'm a rationalist. Religion is irrational because it claims there's a reality beyo…

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

26 Feb 2016 Australia News Vatican Comments (2)

Cardinal Muller on proselytism, "Sometimes a silent witness is the best witness of the love of God"

Cardinal Gerhard Müller of Germany, Vatican's Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith says proselytism 'is practically a manipulation of the c…

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

07 Oct 2014 Vatican No comments

Pope Francis to make apostolic voyage to France in 2015

Vatican City, Oct 7, 2014 / 05:55 am .- In their announcement of the Pope’s schedule for his visit to the European Parliament next month, the Vatican also revea…

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

28 Oct 2015 Americas News No comments

Hurricane Patricia befalls Mexico

Catholics in Mexico expressed their gratitude to God in a thanksgiving mass on Sunday for saving them from Hurricane Patricia. Late on October 23rd, Hurrican…

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

26 Sep 2016 News No comments

'He grows in the love of the spouses' - Exorcist warns families of devil's infuence

There's a demon that specializes in attacking the family, said exorcist César Truqui, a priest who participated in a course on exorcism held in Rome last year. …

Read more
An error occured during creating the thumbnail.

05 Feb 2016 Americas News Vatican Comments (1)

Pope Francis, a renowned football fan meets former football legend Ronaldinho

Former Brazilian football Legend Ronaldo de Assis Moreira commonly known as Ronaldinho met with Pope Francis earlier this week, precisely on Wednesday. Ronal…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
«
»

Why don’t Christian Scientists allow doctors to treat them?

Full Question

I know someone who is a Christian Scientist, and he doesn’t believe in going to a doctor when he gets sick. He tells me it’s against his religion. Can you explain this to me?

Answer

In order to answer this question a little of the background on the Christian Science sect is necessary. It was founded by Mary Baker Eddy (1821-1910), whose teachings are set forth in the book Science and Health with Key to the Scriptures, first published in 1875. The book describes a belief system Eddy claims to have “discovered” in 1866.

Throughout her early life, Eddy suffered from various emotional and physical illnesses. As a result she developed a morbid fear of the medical profession. She began to view the physical world as an illusion and maintained that the only reality was the spiritual world–possibly as a defense mechanism to deal with the difficulties of her sicknesses.

To Eddy, truth (which she calls “the divine Principle” or “divine Life, Truth, and Love”) is a healing spiritual force. She believed that Jesus came to enlighten humanity regarding this truth: “Jesus taught the way of Life by demonstration, that we may understand how this divine Principle heals the sick, casts out error, and triumphs over death” (Science and Health [1971 ed.], 25). The material or physical world, she maintained, is illusory, a product of a wrong perception of our true spiritual nature.

According to Christian Science, things like sickness, suffering, pain, and sin have no objective reality. So when humans experience these things, they are guilty of misperceptions-what Christian Scientists call “error.” Christ came to provide spiritual and physical healing by correcting our wrong perceptions. For the Christian Scientist, Christ’s passion and death were ways he demonstrated his triumph over wrong thinking rather than being a physical reality he endured: “Jesus bore our infirmities; he knew the error of mortal belief, and ‘with his stripes [the rejection of error] we are healed'” (Science and Health, 20; brackets in original).

Of course, the problem here is that Scripture–as well as human experience–paints a radically different picture. Christ did not come to destroy mere “illusion” or “error.” He came to destroy the objective realityof sin and its tangible results: pain, sickness, suffering, and physical death itself. This is why Paul says, “If Christ was not raised, your faith is worthless. You are still in your sins” (1 Cor 15:17). There is not even a hint here of something illusory or immaterial. Christ’s death and resurrection were objectively real, historical events which triumphed over humanity’sactual sins.

So for your friend to consider a visit to the doctor, he would be guilty of not having applied the “Truth” or “divine Principle” which Christ taught. In his mind he is not experiencing an objective illness but rather “error,” or a mistaken perception that he is sick. Therefore, going to a doctor in search of a physical cure would be diametrically opposed to his belief system and would only fuel the fire of his “error.”










1 comment

  1. watchingforwisdom Reply

    I don’t know anything about your friend, but I can speak for myself (as a Christian Scientist) that there have been times in my life when I just told people that it’s against my religion to go to doctors, or to drink, or to have premarital sex (whatever the case may be) simply because it is an easy explanation and saves me the trouble of getting into an extended conversation about theology. I would guess that you friend would be happy to talk more about his beliefs and health care decisions with you if you approach it gently from a position of sincere curiosity and understanding.

    Also, I want to make a few corrections to the historical narrative that is supplied here in the answer. It is true that Mary Baker Eddy, the founder of the Christian Science and discovered of the system of healing that she named Christian Science (CS), dealt with fragile health for much of her childhood and adult life. In particular, she suffered from serious injuries following a fall on ice in the winter of 1866, which the attending doctor could not remedy, and so she turned to her Bible. Shortly thereafter, she experienced a rapid and complete healing. From that point on, she began to study the Bible more deeply in order to understand how she was healed. Her discovery of CS was not the result of “morbid fear of the medical profession.” In fact, she explains in Science and Health and other writings that she had tremendous respect for medical professionals and that she felt that they had a common mission in the alleviation of suffering.

    Additionally, I just want to clarify that CS does not teach its students to avoid doctors. There is no prohibition anywhere in this teaching of seeking medical attention. CS teaches that prayer and a right understanding of man’s spiritual nature and relationship with his Father-Mother God restores health and harmony, and that that is something we can rely on to handle any kind of challenge, including health challenges. Each individual is free to choose whatever kind of remedy that they want for any given problem, and there are no consequences (e.g. excommunication, eternal damnation, etc…) for choosing medical care.

    If anyone is interested in additional information the Wikipedia article on Christian Science (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Christian_Science) offers a pretty impartial explanation, or you can read about it from the people who understand it best (the Christian Scientists themselves) at christianscience.com.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories