Follow usTwitterFacebook


26 Dec 2014 Q&A No comments

Who were the Judaizers?

Full Question I hear a good deal about the Judaizers. Who were they? Answer The Judaizers were a sect of early Christians who believed Gentiles h…

Read more

01 Aug 2016 News No comments

Next World Youth Day to be held in Panama

In his homily, the Pope said God 'demands of us real courage, the courage to be more powerful than evil' Pope Francis has announced that the next World Youth D…

Read more

08 Feb 2016 Europe News Vatican No comments

Pope Francis might visit Scotland

Pope Francis could in September this year be travelling to Scotland. A professor of religion and politics at St Andrews University, Mario Aguilar, received a…

Read more

16 Oct 2015 News Vatican No comments

Do aliens exist? Pope Francis tackles this (and other things) in new interview

Pope Francis discussed in a new interview topics ranging from his reasons for canonizing the parents of St. Therese of Lisieux, to his thoughts on whether there…

Read more

16 Oct 2015 Middle East - Africa News Vatican Comments (2)

A synod conversation with Catholic Africa’s lion in winter

ROME — Supposedly Pope Paul VI once flirted with the idea of naming patriarchs for each of the world’s continents, as a step towards greater local control. Alth…

Read more

10 Oct 2016 News No comments

Justin Welby to preach in Westminster Cathedral at close of Year of Mercy

The Church of England leader has been invited to speak at a service in Westminster Cathedral In an email to priests, the Diocese of Westminster has said Archbi…

Read more

25 Sep 2015 News USA No comments

Pope Francis to women religious: where would the Church be without you?

At Vespers the Pope also warned priests and religious in New York against 'worldly comfort' During an evening prayer service at St Patrick’s Cathedral in New Y…

Read more

19 Jan 2016 News Vatican No comments

A vote of Thanks to Vatican security from Pope Francis

The Holy Father on January 18th welcomed an audience of the Vatican security in meeting held at the Clementine Hall. The Holy Father thanked them for their serv…

Read more

13 Apr 2016 Articles Comments (1)

Why Miracles Are Not Incompatible with Science

Skeptics argue that miracles are impossible because the laws of nature are necessary. A miracle, they argue, involves a violation of a law of nature. But the la…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Why was Zechariah punished for his lack of belief, while Mary wasn’t?

Full Question

Why was Zechariah punished for his lack of belief in the archangel Gabriel’s message (Luke 1:18–20), but Mary was not punished for hers (Luke 1:26–38)?


Zechariah’s objection was that “I am an old man, and my wife is advanced in years.” But as a religiously educated Jew and a priest of the temple, he knew that Abraham and Sarah, the founding patriarch and matriarch of the Jewish people, had been granted a son late in life. By asking for another sign, he demonstrated a lack of faith that God could and would provide.

Mary’s question was entirely different. It implies that she was not expecting to have marital relations with Joseph, because otherwise she would have assumed that the pregnancy would take place within her upcoming marriage, and so she needs information about how it is possible for a woman to have a baby without having had relations with a man. After Gabriel explains that the Holy Spirit would accomplish the task, she accepts without further question.


1 comment

  1. Patrick Gannon Reply

    Why should we believe this story from the author of Luke? Mark, the first gospel, has no such virgin birth, Matthew’s version is quite different, and John who had the earlier three gospels to refer to, refutes the whole idea by refusing to even place it in his gospel.
    In any case, she was not asked for consent. The prophecy it derives from in Isaiah uses the word “almah” which meant young maiden, There was another word ‘betulah’ that more specifically meant ‘virgin’ that could have been used if it was as maniacally critical to Isaiah as it is to the RCC that she be a virgin. Many of the pagan gods were born of virgins, so it was sort of expected.
    While we’re on the subject, let’s review the premise. An all-powerful being impregnates a young woman without her consent, with Himself, in order to sacrifice Himself to Himself, so that He could relieve us of a condition that He placed on us in the first place.
    We know He has the power to forgive this condition without this rigamarole because the RCC says He did it for Mary, after they learned that women contribute 50% to the offspring and aren’t just a carrier for the man’s seed, and thus were also passing along “original sin” through that nasty sex thing. It was declared that Mary was born without original sin, which tells us that Yahweh really doesn’t need all this rigamarole in order to do the right thing and stop sending aborted, miscarried or stillborns to Hell because they have original sin.
    And what of this so-called “sacrifice”? What kind of sacrifice is it if you already know in advance that you will be resurrected and will not die? That’s not a sacrifice.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories