Follow usTwitterFacebook


25 Jul 2016 News No comments

World Youth Day 2016: full schedule

World Youth Day 2016 is taking place in Krakow this week and the Pope is taking part in a number of events Tuesday, July 26 Opening Mass (Błonia Park, 5…

Read more

02 Oct 2015 Articles Comments (2)

The origin of the Christmas Tree

The story of the Christmas tree is part of the story of the life of St. Boniface, whose name was originally Winfrid.  St. Boniface was born about the year 680 i…

Read more

06 Nov 2014 Q&A Comments (26)

Can Catholics be cremated? I was taught that cremation is a pagan ritual and therefore forbidden.

Full Question Can Catholics be cremated? I was taught that cremation is a pagan ritual and therefore forbidden. Answer Early Christians opposed…

Read more

02 Dec 2014 Articles Comments (4)

Three Reasons to Be Porn-Free

There are good reasons to decide to live a porn-free life: it’s a sin; it can be addictive; it objectifies people; and so forth. In this post, howe…

Read more

05 Sep 2014 Vatican No comments

Peres says Francis only leader capable of ending today's wars

Peres said that “perhaps for the first time in history, the Holy Father is a leader who’s respected, not just by a lot of people, but also by different religion…

Read more

19 Nov 2016 News No comments

Mexican Mayor kills 300 people, who he ordered incinerated in network of ovens

Mexican authorities have arrested a former mayor who may have participated in over 300 drug killings in his village. Sergio Alonzo Rodriguez was mayor in Allend…

Read more

28 Jan 2016 Articles Comments (1)

Waiting for the Culture to Turn

I was reading an aviation magazine. The senior editor contributed a column on “what to do if you bend an airplane.” It was a discussion of the differences…

Read more

29 Aug 2016 Americas News USA Vatican No comments

Heartbroken couple forcibly separated after 62-years of marriage

Wolf and Anita Gottschalk have been forcibly separated for eight months, leaving a ripple of broken hearts across the internet. The Gottschalks have been mar…

Read more

17 Feb 2016 Articles News No comments

Love Means Not Withholding the Truth

Like most people, I don’t like going to the dentist. And if we consider the measure of discomfort that is inflicted on us when we do go, then we realize it is o…

Read more
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3

Why young Catholics love the Extraordinary Form

But don’t expect them to disparage the Novus Ordo

As a young Catholic growing up in an increasingly secular (or even post-secular) Britain, I am lucky to be able to attend the Extraordinary Form of the Mass. There is something about the purity and beauty of the Catholic culture that it represents that I, and many other young Catholics, find enticing.

The Latin, the Gregorian chant, the priest facing ad orientem and even the Roman biretta are ingredients in a spiritual feast that represents an oasis of replenishing beauty from the madness of the modern world.

I love the Extraordinary Form because it is so unashamedly and distinctively Catholic. It represents a brave and missionary faith willing to take on the world, and affirm our identity in so doing. It is the Mass of the greatest popes and saints of the Church’s long history and stands apart from so much of the culture of our day: a battle standard for spiritual combat with the forces of evil.

Most importantly, it is something that the younger generations of Catholics covet as something nearly lost. Its value is heightened by the fact that we never grew up with it. And now we have easier access to the Form, we do make the most of it: last year I attended an Extraordinary Form Requiem for All Souls’ Day in York. Fauré’s Requiem was sung by the choir at St Wilfrid’s Church which, combined with the solemnity and dignity of the celebration, helped give the Mass great numinosity. Fortunately for me, such splendour is available weekly.

However, it would be wrong to assume that solemnity, beauty and spiritual armour cannot be found within the rich folds of the Novus Ordo Mass, a liturgy which has its own merits and which I am proud to have grown up with. I admire the way that the glorious essence of the Mass is made more accessible through the structural simplifications of the Novus Ordo, which are appealing in themselves. This gives the Mass a sense of versatility and of course brings the laity into the celebration. A liturgy in the vernacular is also not without its benefits. All in all it is, arguably, a cleaner weapon than the Extraordinary Form, which is far more theatrical and splendid.

I remarked above that part of the value of the Extraordinary Form is that it has been shaped by the faith of the Church over the past 1,500 years. I feel the correct view of the Novus Ordo would be to see it as another development in the long – and unfinished – history of the Church. It was born out of the Second Vatican Council, and has therefore been shaped by the witness of the Church and the leadership of great popes, many of whom – St John XXIII, Blessed Paul VI and St John Paul the Great – gaze upon the beatific vision because of their service to the Church, of which their role in the establishment of the Novus Ordo was a key element.

Furthermore, who can deny the orthodoxy and holiness of Pope Emeritus Benedict XVI or – despite secular media coverage to the contrary – Pope Francis? These men are dedicated to the Novus Ordo, as their predecessors were.

In discussing particular devotions to particular liturgies – a discussion not limited to these two Forms, lest we forget the Eastern Catholic Church – we must remember that we all belong to the same tradition. Indeed, to overzealously stress the importance of one Form over another sets the Church on a path to serious internal division.

The unfortunate Society of St Pius X is a prime example of this. Elements of this group claim that the Novus Ordo is an insult to God, and deny the validity of the canonisation of St John Paul the Great. Extremism makes idiots of us all.

I could go further into Archbishop Marcel Lefebvre’s supposed issues with the documents of the Second Vatican Council. But, since he signed them, I don’t think there’s much point.

I would stress that all Catholics should be appalled by the heterodox abuses of the liturgy in the immediate post-conciliar decades. Regardless of which Form you celebrate, the Mass ought to be the most beautiful thing on earth, as befits the sacramental reality.

I give heartfelt thanks to Benedict XVI for his motu proprio Summorum Pontificum. This marvellous document allows Catholics to celebrate both Forms of the Roman Rite of the Mass in a way that enables the tradition to self-fertilise and increasingly enrich itself. We should not see the different Forms as the battle standards of opposed factions within the Church, but as a valuable expansion of our arsenal as we strive for the conversion of the culture.





  1. Tom Rafferty Reply

    When I read a comment like this, I can only think of “rearranging the chairs on the deck of the Titanic” meme. Really, if you like all that external superficial stuff, get involved with watching play, dancing, et all. I challenge you to get out of your comfort zone and meet reality: Peace.

    1. Elizabeth Korf Reply

      And I challenge you to open your heart. I can hold faith, science, and reason. To bad you have closed self off from at least one of those.

      1. Tom Rafferty Reply

        Too bad you hold one the superstitious, ignorant one as valuable, and not the other two that deal with reality. What knowledge does faith give you? How do you know YOUR brand is true? Peace.

        1. Elizabeth Korf Reply

          Well if I’m wrong, nothing happens. If you’re wrong and I’m right you suffer a very unpleasant fate, So from where I’m sitting I get the best of both worlds. I have science and reason as well as a back up plan.

          1. Tom Rafferty

            I’ll live with my clear conscience informed by evidence, you can live with your fear created by your church. Google the fallacy of Pascal’s Wager. Peace.

        2. Elizabeth Korf Reply

          I also have a piece in my choices and world vies which apparently you don’t because you find the need to troll on Catholic websites.

  2. Elizabeth Korf Reply

    We long for the beauty and piety of the EF and Eastern Rite liturgy. I did not find these qualities in the EF, as you did, but instead in the Ordinariate Mass. You are correct a well done NO mass can also meet the needs of our generation but all too often our generation leaves the Church because their needs are not being met, or in some cases they don’t even know what they are seeking. I think more of our generation should explore the different forms and rites of the Mass seeking what their soul longs for rather than leaving the Church. As a priest friend of mine says, “the Catholic church is a Big Church with lots of varied histories. It has something for everyone.” Just make sure that you are following the church’s core teachings while looking for your style.

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories