Does my husband have the power to take my children to his Church even though i forbid it?

By November 21, 2014 7 Comments

Question from anonymous on 6/16/2011:
My husband has been attending a local SSPX chapel exclusively for over 2 years. I and our 7 children (ages 3-19) attend a local solid Catholic parish, in obedience to the pope. My husband just told me that, against my will, starting this Sunday he will begin taking the kids with him to his Mass. He doesn’t believe that I (“just” a wife) have the authority to forbid this. I am so lost – I don’t know what to do. Any advice is appreciated. Thank you.
Answer by Colin B. Donovan, STL on 8/3/2011:
First off, this is a fundamentalist view of the authority of a husband, an authority which comes from human nature and the created distinction of male and female. It is a created analogy to the order within the Holy Trinity, which begins with the Father, proceeds to the Son and unites both in the Holy Spirit. If we were divine the world would function just fine with natural authority alone, but we are fallen, limited creatures, prone to self-justification of our sins. This should make every person in authority circumspect about when and how it is exercised. In God what unites is not mere will, but loving will. The Son knows that the Father’s will is the always the wisest and the most loving, and therefore does not His own will but the will of the Father. The Holy Trinity is thus a perfect communion in which justice and love, authority and obedience, are perfectly realized and can never be in opposition.
Not so with fallen creatures. And so Christ came to fulfill and perfect justice, and redeem authority, so that by grace it might achieve what the Father intends, and which the Trinity lives. Toward that end, He told the apostles that their leadership should be one of servanthood, not lordship, and He, who is truly Lord and God, served them. This is the Christian model of the relationship of authority and obedience.
St. Paul in Ephesians 3:14-15, referring to the Divine natural order lived in communion, states that the Father (pater) is the source of all fatherhood (patria). Some translations say “families,” which seems a weaker affirmation, thought the paternal root remains. Later in Eph 5:21-30, he affirms this natural order, but as situated within the supernatural order of a leadership of love. For a Christian, specifically one in a sacramental marriage, this is the only way to live the Faith in marriage – not simply as a natural family unit, but as a supernatural one.
Finally, it is odd to speak so adamantly of husbandly authority when the divine authority of the pope and the bishop is being ignored. No one can be obliged to sin, even under the color of authority, and although he may be subjectively guiltless of sinning against the obedience he owes to the Church’s proper pastors, or of not remaining in perfect communion with the Church, he cannot obliged you to violate your conscience and the far more reasonable position that the Church is where the Pope is, not where the SSPX is. As the ancient Latin axiom states, it, “Ubi Petrus ibi ecclesia, et ibi ecclesia vita eternal” (Where Peter is there is the Church, and where the Church is there is life eternal).


  • Bruce Wienckowski says:

    What academic automaton advises a person with text book answers rather than love and compassion? This forgets the human condition and leaves the laity wanting. Have a little sensitivity and empathy for your people!

  • Pachomius says:

    This site isn’t ran by a Catholic Church is it? Church law says if both parents are Catholic, the children are to be raised in the parrish of their father!

  • no it says that if you getting married to a non Catholic that you must agree that your children are to be raised in the Catholic Church ..

    • Vicki Sawarin says:

      Avril, you are right. But what is a SSPX church ? She says that he takes them to Mass. Isn’t Mass only in a catholic church?

      • Sara Lynn says:

        Vicki, SSPX are not unified with the Catholic Church. Pope Benedict XVI tried to reunite them, but he never accomplished that… and I guess Pope Francis is too busy bashing capitalism to try.

  • Erika says:

    I feel your pain. Your situation must be real hard and even seem, at times, unbearable. Carry your cross with patience and trust in God.
    If you were married in the Catholic Church, then, during your preparation class, you must (both) have signed a paper saying that you promised to raise your children in the Catholic Faith. Remind your husband that he made that promise (a binding promise) before the Church/God, whom the minister represents, and before you. To change his mind now, is to break a promise that he made to you and to the Church/God. His signature sealed that promise. Tell him to honor his name and man up to his promise.


    St Paul the apostle gave his counsel to husband and wife in one of his epistles in Scripture, which is divinely inspired; that wives should submit to their husbands and husbands should love their wives. Submitting to your husband does not mean you enslaved, but in obedience to the word of God and keeping the word. In so doing, remind your husband about the marrital vows/promises you both made. But do so with prayer.
    When a man and a woman and joined together in marriage as husband and wife, they become one person. It is only the devil that will try influence a difference. So the victim should pray to God to bring the light of truth to your family; pray with faith.

Leave a Reply Brethren !