Follow usTwitterFacebook

Insurance denied her chemo treatment. But it covered drugs for suicide.




Stephanie Packer cherishes every moment with her husband and four children. Living with a terminal illness in Orange, California, her goal is “to do everything I can to have one more second with my kids.”

When assisted suicide legislation was officially passed in California in 2016, Packer experienced the ultimate slap in the face: her insurance company denied the coverage of critical chemotherapy treatment that her doctors recommended for her condition.

Her insurance would, however, cover end-of-life drugs for just $1.20.

“It was like someone had just hit me in the gut,” said Packer, who shared her story in the documentary, Compassion and Choice Denied.

Produced by the Center for Bioethics and Culture Network, the documentary details Packer’s experience of living with a terminal illness in an age where assisted suicide is cheaper than the fight for life.

Particularly concerning: the insurance company had initially suggested that they would cover the chemotherapy drugs. It was one week after assisted suicide was legalized that they sent Packer a letter saying they were denying coverage. Despite multiple appeals, they continued to refuse.

“As soon as this law was passed, patients fighting for a longer life end up getting denied treatment, because this will always be the cheapest option… it’s hard to financially fight,” Packer said in the documentary.

Physician-assisted suicide is legal in a handful of states, gaining momentum ever since the high profile suicide of cancer patient Brittany Maynard in 2014.

Many prominent Catholic leaders, such as Pope Francis, have spoken out against assisted suicide, calling it “false compassion.” Los Angeles Archbishop Jose Gomez has said that assisted suicide “represents a failure of solidarity” and abandons the most vulnerable in society.

“We are called as people to support each other, to hold each other’s hand and walk through this journey,” Packer said, adding, “I want my kids to see that dying is a part of life, and the end of your life can be an opportunity to appreciate the things you didn’t appreciate before.”

Packer leads support groups for individuals with terminal and chronic illnesses. She said there was a clear morale change in many of the group members when physician-assisted suicide became legalized in her state.

“Normally, we would talk about support and love, and we would be there for each other, and just encourage them that, you know, today is a bad day, tomorrow doesn’t have to be,” she said.

But when assisted suicide was legalized, individuals became more depressed, with some saying that they wanted to end their lives.

“Patients are going to die because of this,” Packer said. “Patients need to know what this means, and the public needs to know that it’s going to kill these patients because they aren’t going to get the treatment they need to extend their life.”

She also said that assisted suicide proponents have twisted the meaning of suicide to make it sound “sweet and pretty,” and have also redefined what it means to live with a terminal illness.

“It makes terminally ill patients feel ‘less than,’ that they are not worthy of that fight, that they’re not worth it,” she said.

Packer believes that end-of-life drugs should never “be supported by physicians or run by the government. That’s not okay… because it affects me negatively and affects my fight and my ability to stay here longer with my children.”

Packer pointed to other resources, saying that there is a whole treasury of support for terminal patients – financially, psychologically, physically, and even if patients just need someone to talk to.

While life-affirming palliative care remains an expensive medical cost, Packer recommended that more energy and resources fund hospice care, instead of making death the cheaper option.

“We can start to fix our broken health care system, and people will start to live instead of feeling like they have to choose to die.”

This article was originally published on CNA Oct. 19, 2016.





wpsd_autopost:
1

2 comments

  1. Peter Aiello Reply

    In Proverbs 8:36, God says “all they that hate me love death”. This is what is naturally happening in California.

  2. Patrick Gannon Reply

    This article is essentially a lie. It completely misrepresents the situation. The insurance company did not offer suicide in place of chemo – Ms Packer asked what suicide would cost, after learning that her new chemo drug was not covered. As an anti-suicide activist, Ms Packer wants to enjoy the suffering that her god imposed on her. That’s fine. However, that does not give her the right to deny others the opportunity to end their own suffering, or for her to viciously insist that others should suffer.
    .
    The details of the story presented here appear to be badly misrepresenting the real situation – but should we actually expect a Catholic organization to tell the truth when they have an agenda? Of course not.
    .
    Packer is concerned that some people are going to be depressed and end their lives. So what? How is that any of her business? What right does she and the Church have to deny others the right to make their own end-of-life decisions for themselves? Such cruel and vicious arrogance on the part of the Church… .
    .
    http://www.patheos.com/blogs/secularvoices/2016/10/24/no-insurance-company-not-offer-assisted-suicide-place-chemotherapy/

Leave a Reply

  1. most read post
  2. Most Commented
  3. Choose Categories