May a Priest Violate the Seal of the Confessional in Order to Save a Life?

An interview with Cardinal Mauro Piacenza, Major Penitentiary of the Vatican

Approximately 200 confessors participated in a congress that took place this November 12-13 at the Palace of the Roman Chancery, organized by the Apostolic Penitentiary, regarding the seal of confession and pastoral privacy.  For this occasion, Aleteia interviewed Cardinal Mauro Piacenza, Major Penitentiary of the Vatican.

Cardinal Piacenza confirms that these are very relevant topics in a society where the media play such a large role, considering the need to protect the privacy of people to turn to the Church. Privacy becomes a “caring and attentive gesture to protect souls” in the face of the fad of wanting to know everything about other people by using the internet, such as examining their profile on a social network.

Privacy as a value
In this context, Piacenza draws attention to an “excessive media explosion” that threatens people and their values, and he affirms that in the Church, “privacy is important.”

“The human person should have an environment or a place in which one can be oneself and not what others expect one to be.” For this reason, “we want to protect very important ‘goods’ through privacy and confidentiality” in order to “protect the good name, the reputation or the rights of individuals and of groups,” he explains.

“It is a fundamental task of the priest to defend and preserve the intimacy of the person as a vital space for protecting one’s personality, as well as one’s feelings,” he clarifies.

And, he indicates that in the specific case of a pastor, to give a concrete example, “he offers a service of material and spiritual assistance” and is obliged to defend the “private interior life” of the people who visit the parish or the church.

Along these lines, the cardinal highlights that “the purpose of secrecy, sacramental or not sacramental” is to defend “the private interior life of the person, which consists in protecting the presence of God inside each human being.”

And he quotes St. Augustine to uphold the great value of private interior life: “God is superior summo meo et interior intimo meo (God is above what is highest in me and is deeper inside me than my own interior).”

The cardinal warns that for the Church, whoever violates “a person’s private interior life” commits an “act of injustice” which also contradicts the spirit of religion. In this sense, he confirms that the congress is an answer to this need for dialogue with today’s world.

The seal of confession
Are there exceptions to the seal of confession?

No. The seal is absolute and inviolable I am obliged to maintain confidentiality regarding everything that is said to me.  The penitent does not speak to the priest as a man; rather, he or she speaks to God. The confessor does not even know what he has felt, because as a man he does not know what he has heard.

What is said in confession is directed to the Good Shepherd. According to the classic doctrine the confessor is forbidden to cultivate any memory of what he has heard. If, in some moment, it comes to mind, he should reject it, as he would reject any other illicit or evil thought.

What are the consequences foreseen in canon law for a priest who violates the seal of confession?

Excommunication.  It is a very serious punishment. Breaking the seal of confession means betraying a person’s conversation with God.  A violation may be direct or indirect. In the latter case, it is as if the priest were to make an allusion to other people about something that someone said in confession.

Are there priests who have lost their lives to maintain the seal of confession?

In totalitarian regimes, and with the complicity of some laws, there has been a desire to violate the strength of the seal of confession in order to know things about other people. In several regimes what you ask has happened, and in those cases the priests have been true martyrs of the faith.

For example, St. John Nepomucine suffered martyrdom rather than give in to pressure from the King of Bohemia, who wanted to know if the queen had been unfaithful to him. St.  John was the queen’s confessor.

Therefore, the law of a country cannot oblige a priest to violate the seal of confession…

If a law says that a confessor must report a person who has come to confess a crime, obviously the priest cannot do so.

The Supreme Court of Louisiana, USA, in July of 2014, ordered a priest to bear witness, breaking the seal of confession. Faced with that request, the diocese of Baton Rouge insisted that this request is unconstitutional and attacks Church doctrine. Do you have any comment about this case?

The duties of our mission cannot be violated in any way.  It is a duty even more serious than that of professional secrecy. The diocese responded well.

What is the position of the Holy See when the seal of confession is threatened by the laws of a State?

The Holy See tries not to interfere in the decisions of countries and their policies. The Church  respects freedom—not the will of countries’ laws, but true freedom. Faith is a free act. The Church should demand and defend freedom of worship, freedom to evangelize, and the sacrament of confession. If the State doesn’t respect this, the Church suffers martyrdom.

Can a priest violate the secret of confession in order to save the life of another person who has been unjustly condemned?

No. The Church defends life always and to the end. It lives these values at its core. A confessor should embrace martyrdom in his heart. He can do whatever is possible to save life through prayer, penance and personal witness. However, he may never speak up to say that that person is the murderer. That is something he can never say.

Raphael Benedict

Raphael Benedict is a Catholic who wants nothing but to spread the catholic faith to reach the ends of the world. Make this possible by always sharing any article or prayers posted on your social media platforms. Remain blessed

Related Articles

Leave a Reply