Should I Attend My Daughter’s Same-Sex ‘Marriage’?




Full Question

My daughter is having a same-sex marriage. Everybody says that, as her father, I should go. What do you have to say?

Answer

Your daughter certainly needs to know that you love her, and it’s important that you do all you can to maintain communication with her. But part of loving her is not affirming her in gravely immoral decisions. Some would say you can go to the ceremony but express your disapproval otherwise. However, there is the maxim that “actions speak louder than words,” and if “everyone” is telling you to attend—I infer that doesn’t include your parish pastor—it’s all the more important that you not provide public support for your daughter’s decision. She will benefit from your witness, as will many others.

While U.S. law recognizes such relationships as “marriages,” God and the Catholic Church never can. Scripture and the Church’s magisterium otherwise teach that homosexual sex—whether between two men or two women—is an intrinsic moral evil, let alone attempting to publicly sanction such a relationship. And the Church distinguishes between same-sex attraction (SSA) and homosexual acts (see CCC 2357-59). Only the latter are condemned.

We can also affirm the genuine love that two people with SSA have for each other, but the attempted sexual expression of that love can never be legitimized. The obvious lack of bodily complementarity illustrates that one need not invoke God to make a compelling argument against homosexual sex. And trying to live chastely but as an exclusive “couple” is not recommended, either.

I suggest that you, your daughter, and others concerned view the documentary Desire of the Everlasting Hills, which the faithful Catholic apostolate Courage has produced. I also invite you to read a commentary I have written on ministering to those with SSA. God bless your efforts.

By  Tom Nash





wpsd_autopost:
1

16 comments

  1. thomraff Reply

    This post is a good example of the harm from religion. The Catholic Church is against same-sex marriage solely because of its Tradition based on dogma. Science has shown that sex and gender are not binary, but both are on continuums. I attended the same-sex wedding of my Catholic-raised niece and it was well-attended and beautiful. It is amazing how reality is so much clearer without the fog of unsupported dogma.

    1. Informationista Reply

      This post saddens me greatly. Love is love. I think you should attend your daughter’s wedding. I fear you will regret it one day. I fear you will lose your relationship with your daughter. As a parent, you should have and show unconditional love for your children. Attending her same sex wedding will deeply express your unconditional love. Your daughter has to make it right with her maker. That is up to her. And I believe that God is shining down on her brightly. Go to the wedding. Celebrate your daughter’s union with another person that she loves.

    2. RLY08 Reply

      Have you not read that He who made them from the beginning made them MALE and FEMALE, for this reason a MAN shall leave his father and mother and be joined to his wife and the two shall become one?

      Do you know what dogmas are?
      You talk about Catholic tradition, but you and others with the same ideas as yours are creating your own tradition.

      You or anyone else can’t prove God’s existence in the way you want Him to be proven. In simple language, you’re looking for God in the wrong direction.

      Bishop Barron talks about that kind of searching for God as “scientism”.

      You try to prove everything thru science. But it’s wrong to reduce all knowledge thru science. Reducing all knowledge thru science is scientism. Because there are so much things that science can’t prove. You forgot about philosophy. Philosophy is also finding truth but not using the scientific way.

      What is the scientific way? Observation, formulate hypothesis, do lots of testing, then draw a conclusion.

      If anyone reduce all knowledge to this kind of thinking then they won’t reveal so many things. All they have are facts that are still and constantly changing. (Pluto is now a planet and dinosaurs now have feathers) With all the things that science reveal, it still can’t prove God or anything so definitely. If you have faith science that much then everything that Hamlet, shakespeare, aristotle or other great minds that has revealed, not thru science but thru philosophy, about the human heart and human mind and soul would be discredited.

      If you want to stick with science, well, science has the burden of proving God, not religion. Because from the start, even before science came around, people first believed in a god or a superior being.

      Science and religion are two different beliefs but they don’t contradict each other. Science arguably answers the “how”, religion on the other hand answers the “why”.

  2. Patrick Gannon Reply

    “Your daughter certainly needs to know that you love her…” but you should illustrate this by doing the most cruel and heartless thing you can think of to hurt her. Yeah, that makes sense.
    .
    This is part of the reason that Christianity is going to fail. We have had enough of this hostility and hate and manic obsession with sex. This is why the NONE’s are the fastest growing :”religious” group. This is why there are so many “recovering Catholics,” and why the youth are abandoning the Church.

    1. jcoesmyth Reply

      Same sex is not natural how would humanity move forward and multiply

  3. Liz Campbell Reply

    This is not true! My Catholic priest told me to go and attend the wedding! The Lord gave us our daughter to love unconditionally. She knows how we feel about her relationship. She also had to deal and accept that we were there ONLY because we loved her and that we vowed to stand by her no matter what. The scandal that is caused by our attendance was far less than the scandal that it would have caused within our family….grandkids, children. Ultimately, we pray for all our souls because we are all sinners. We just have different sins to work on!

    1. Lisa F. Reply

      I wholeheartedly agree with your response. Unconditional love is and always will be for our children and your last two sentences no truer words have been spoken!

  4. Arlene Rosival Reply

    Thom raff ,you are wrong it is written in the Bible first, and as always the Church obeys GOD’S LAWS, LV: 18:22 A man shall not lay with a man as with a woman , it is an abomination !! Same sex attraction no different than Homosexual acts, if you are attracted , then you are lusting! And the sex act will ensue, Agreeing to same sex marriage,is going against GOD’S LAW ,AND CATHOLIC CHURCH TEACHING . THEOLOGIONS ARE EXPERTS GO TO EWTN.COM ! Try can answer every question you want!

    1. thomraff Reply

      I have tried getting answers to my questions from EWTN.com but they don’t seem to want to attempt to do so. My first simple question is: why should I accept what the Church says on anything when science has refuted the concept of a god, let alone the Christian variety of such? Please answer that, or agree that you have no reason to accept the Church’s teaching over science. Can you be honest with yourself?

      1. RLY08 Reply

        Have you ever wonder why the heart, when it stops beating, it doesn’t beat again?
        And what makes the heart beat from the start?
        Science may answer or give reasons to that answer, electric shock, etc. But still can’t answer what makes the heart beat and what makes it stop.

      2. RLY08 Reply

        And I think you have to ponder on that.

  5. Samuel Reply

    May Christ hv MERCY on all those who claim to be Christians but does not know what it takes to obey it’s teachings.

  6. Daniel Donovan Reply

    So many try to make God bend to their will. They have their own ideas what love is and are duped into this earthly “love is love” mentality.
    To truly love someone is to care about their soul, and to help them on the path to God and heaven. If you need proof look at what Christ did for us.
    Homosexuality is not what God intended for us. This is a temptation of Satan and without faith more people are getting confused and falling in to his snare. I pray for our world, it’s very confused right now.

    1. thomraff Reply

      Daniel, you are the poster child (and, I intentionally used that term because your thinking is infantile) for why religion poisons everything. I just encourage you to take a DEEP breath and look at what you are saying.

  7. Ivin Reply

    Thomraff what are you insinuating?? That homosexualism is right?? Let me know where to start answering and arguing with you..

  8. Jesus is love Reply

    Jesus is love and mercy and that is what he wants us to teach, we are here to love each other, not our place to judge each other although we are required to right our children when they are going down a wrong path, at the same time here, none of us have a clear answer, but you love your child, she is your child and she needs that physical acknowledgement of your love by your presence. Let Jesus determine what is right or wrong when we are all called to judgement, but the bible says and this is why I get annoyed that it is used to stop people from building a relationship with the father and son, is that they are mercy and love we need to stop putting boundaries on these two things.

Leave a Reply to RLY08 Cancel reply