When is it superstitious or wrong to carry a Rosary? Is it superstitious to trust in your Rosary for protection?
I do not think there’s anything wrong with believing in the protection that God and his saints offer by using some sacramental. However, if you believe that by merely carrying a rosary in your person and not using it, that the Rosary itself will protect you, then it is superstitious; however, if you believe that by carrying it and praying it, that God, our Lady, and the Saints will protect and come to your aid. Not just for physical protection but for spiritual advancement and protection, then that is okay. The Rosary itself doesn’t protect you, God protects us, and his Saints help us by praying to him for us and by protecting us also by the power of God in them.
We use sacramental to get closer to God and his Saints, seek their aid and intercession and be protected from darkness and sin. So it is safe to say that using these items presupposes faith and a willingness to struggle against darkness and evil.
I hope this answers your question. God bless and protect you.
When is it superstitious or wrong to carry a Rosary?